"Exploring Disability," authored by Colin
Barnes and Geof Mercer, presents a significant contribution to the advancement
of the social model of disability, offering a revised edition that aligns with
contemporary international discourse and policy initiatives. The book reframes
the experience of disability not as an individual affliction but as a product
of social relationships, reflecting global efforts to promote the rights of
persons with disabilities, such as the United Nations Convention on the Rights
of Persons with Disabilities and the European Disability Strategy 2010–2020.
With approximately one out of four EU citizens living
with some form of disability, and nearly half of them being elderly, the book
addresses a pressing societal issue. Despite increased attention to disability
studies, there remains a need for further sociological discourse in this field.
The second edition builds upon the foundations laid by its predecessor,
published in 1999, to develop disability theory within a sociological
framework. It traces the evolution of disability from a perceived personal
tragedy to a socially constructed condition, providing an extensive review of
pertinent literature in the field.
The book delves into the historical trajectory of
disability in society and policy, with a particular focus on the British experience,
while also drawing comparisons with the regulatory landscape and policies in
the USA. The initial chapters (1–4) explore the historical development of
disability in Western societies, emphasizing the role of grassroots movements
and associations of people with disabilities in driving paradigm shifts. The
analysis begins with Talcott Parsons' functionalist perspective on the
"sick role," progresses to Erving Goffman's concept of
"stigma," and culminates in a post-structuralist examination of
illness narratives.
Throughout the text, Barnes and Mercer critically engage
with key sociological theories and concepts to elucidate the complex dynamics
of disability. They highlight the transformative impact of grassroots activism
in challenging societal perceptions and advocating for systemic change. By
contextualizing disability within broader sociological frameworks, the authors
illuminate the multifaceted nature of disability as a social phenomenon shaped
by historical, cultural, and political factors.
Moreover, the book offers insights into the regulatory
landscape and policy developments surrounding disability, shedding light on the
evolution of disability rights and inclusion efforts. By situating their
analysis within both national and international contexts, Barnes and Mercer
provide a comprehensive understanding of the complexities inherent in
addressing disability within contemporary society.
The socio-historical perspective elucidated in
"Exploring Disability" underscores the entrenched notion of
disability as a "personal tragedy," perpetuated by a medical model
that conflates impairment with disability. However, this perspective has been
challenged by the emergence of the bio-psychosocial model of disability, which
emphasizes the interaction between biological, psychological, and social
factors. Central to this shift is the recognition of the exclusionary
relationship between individuals with impairments and wider society.
The introduction of the social model of disability has
catalyzed the development of diverse social theories, which illuminate
structural barriers and personal experiences shaping disability. Moreover,
there has been a resurgence of interest in the contributions of medical
sociology and social sciences to the understanding of disability, further
enriching the discourse on disability theory.
Chapter 5 delves into disability policy within the
framework of welfare states, shedding light on the pervasive social
inequalities experienced by individuals with disabilities. The chapter underscores
the institutional discrimination prevalent in various spheres of life,
including education, employment, housing, transportation, and leisure. These
structural factors contribute to the marginalization and social exclusion of
people with disabilities, perpetuating inequality and limiting their
participation in society.
In Chapter 6, the authors critically analyze disability
policies, highlighting the gap between formal political rhetoric and the
realities of implementation. Despite efforts to address inequalities and
promote deinstitutionalization through community care initiatives, the authors
argue that recent policies often fall short in their approach and resource
allocation. They critique the underlying ideology of "care," which they
view as oppressive and objectifying, and emphasize the limitations of
mainstream political discourse in achieving substantive change.
The focus shifts to the UK's policy landscape, where
there has been a notable emphasis on the concept of independent living. Grassroots
organizations have played a pivotal role in challenging paternalistic
approaches and advocating for greater autonomy and self-determination for
individuals with disabilities. Their activism has influenced mainstream
political agendas and garnered attention from international organizations such
as the World Bank and the United Nations, signaling a broader recognition of
disability rights on the global stage.
In Chapter 8, the book explores the representation of
disability in culture and media, examining how these narratives shape
disability identity. Drawing on a cultural studies approach, the authors
analyze iconic works such as the film "The Elephant Man,"
illustrating the power of media in perpetuating stereotypes and prejudice. They
underscore the need for more nuanced representations that challenge existing
biases and foster a more inclusive understanding of disability.
The last two chapters of "Exploring Disability"
mark significant contributions in this second edition, addressing contemporary
debates at the forefront of disability studies. Chapter 9 delves into the
complex intersection of the right to life with ethical dilemmas surrounding
euthanasia, eugenics, and advancements in biotechnology. Through critical
analysis, the chapter exposes the limitations of these debates, which often
reinforce the traditional narrative of disability as a personal tragedy, rather
than advocating for meaningful political and social change towards a more
inclusive society.
In contrast, Chapter 10 shifts the focus to a global
perspective, examining the experiences of individuals with disabilities in
developing countries, where poverty, inequality, and disability intersect
within the broader context of capitalist industrialization and globalization.
The chapter underscores the importance of grassroots movements and localized
policy initiatives, rejecting standardized international interventions in favor
of bottom-up approaches. It also emphasizes the emergence of a distinct
globalized disability identity and culture.
"Exploring Disability" serves as a
comprehensive guide to disability theories and approaches. The authors' active
involvement in disability organizations and movements lends credibility to the
scholarly discourse presented in the book. Their contributions have been
instrumental in establishing disability studies as a recognized field of
sociological inquiry, particularly within the UK, where they have played
pivotal roles in institutions such as the Centre for Disability Studies at the
University of Leeds and Disability Press, an independent publishing house
dedicated to disability issues.
Central to the book is its sociological analysis of
disability, which challenges prevailing notions of disability as merely an
individual failing or personal tragedy. Instead, the authors advocate for a
broader investigation encompassing meso and macro levels of analysis,
emphasizing the social construction of disability. While the book offers
valuable insights for students and researchers in disability studies, some areas
could be further developed, particularly the economic dimensions of disability
within the context of economic crises and austerity measures.
Moreover, the book predominantly focuses on the identity
of people with disabilities without fully engaging with intersectional analyses
that explore the interconnectedness of disability with other social categories
such as gender, class, and ethnicity. While the British context is extensively
examined in comparative historical perspective with experiences in the USA, a
more nuanced consideration of disability within a European context would have
enriched the narrative, offering insights into diverse approaches to disability
policy and activism.
No comments:
Post a Comment