Friedrich
Schleiermacher and Wilhelm Dilthey are often considered representatives of
nineteenth-century hermeneutics and hermeneutical philosophy. Schleiermacher's
thought is rooted in the modern appropriation and transformation of traditional
metaphysics and Protestant theology, with his early Romantic works focusing on
the intuition of the infinite and his absolute dependence on God. In contrast,
Dilthey developed an epistemic pluralism and moderate skepticism in response to
metaphysics, distinguishing between natural and human sciences based on their
contexts, methodologies, and objects.
Schleiermacher was a post-Katian thinker of religious transcendence and the
ethical ideal of the highest good that informs and orients ordinary life.
Dilthey, on the other hand, interpreted modernity as an irrevocable break with
premodern forms of thought, including Schleiermacher's dialectics.
Schleiermacher's faith and intuition of the divine lost priority as they became
one way of expressing lived-experience, mood, and worldview, and infinity
became an immanent yet self-interrupting characteristic of life.
Dilthey's works explore the central thread in his critique of historical
reason, focusing on the idea that understanding is an art rather than a
doctrine of science. Hermeneutics is a doctrine of art oriented according to
the idea of understanding given the universality of misunderstanding, and it
requires judgment or a sense of appropriate application that is cultivated.
Schleiermacher's hermeneutics, a philosophical, theological, and scientific
inquiry, emphasizes understanding, judgment, and the role of feeling, desire,
and affectivity in linguistic interaction, interpretation, and individuation.
He critiques rule-based hermeneutics and emphasizes the need for
contextualization and mediation to articulate God's word. Schleiermacher also
discusses psychological interpretation, which involves receptiveness to the
traces of the singularity of the other.
Individuals are irreducible to language, and language is used and created
through the language-forming power and style of individuals. Schleiermacher's
approach is not mere "external reconstruction" aiming at correctness,
but is oriented toward the question of truth through receptivity to what
addresses and claims us.
Language is the only presupposition and defines the scope of hermeneutics, but
it cannot close itself to what is other than language in a pure immanence of
linguistic integration or mediation. The infinitity of sense confronts language
on the side of both the whole and the individual.
Jean Grondin has emphasized the quest for the whole understood as completeness
in Romantic hermeneutics, but the whole is not so much a complete system as an
infinity of intercrossing relations that are ultimately referred to the
nonrelational. Dilthey characterized three senses of "whole" in
Schleiermacher's thought: organizing inner form, system, and relational context
or Zusammenhang.
Schleiermacher's hermeneutics emphasized the correctness of understanding
through theoretical articulation, but he did not presuppose correctness as the
sole model of truth. Interpretation calls for responsive feeling and
imagination, and Schleiermacher also called traces and seeds, which are the
presence of something that cannot be thought as presence, disclosure of
nondisclosedness, and revelation of that which is concealed as concealed.
Werner Hamacher explored Schleiermacher's appeal to the "trace" in
the context of recent literary theory.
Dilthey argued for a nonreductive experientialism in epistemology, expanding it
beyond cognitive or theoretical knowledge and transformating it. He interpreted
the processes of life immanently and in relation to a dynamic context that is
never fully visible. Dilthey believed that the metaphysical unity of the world
is incommensurable and cannot be conclusively combined. He rejected strong
holism in the philosophy of the social sciences and remained a role for weak
holism.
The primary intention of the human sciences is the empirical description of
individuality in its life-context. Dilthey's writings from the early 1890s
should be interpreted in the context of an interpretive psychology occurring in
the space and intersection of epistemology and life. Understanding is the
unending and irreducible intersection of prereflective elementary understanding
and reflexive interpretation between self and other, individual and context,
and singular and whole.
Dilthey's theory of the human sciences is not merely an epistemology but a
theory of knowledge that relates knowing to its context. The human sciences involve
the study of dynamic interconnected systems that articulate the intersection of
meaning, value, purpose, and force. Understanding, which should be construed
verbally as "to understand" (verstehen), is intrinsically
interpretive for Dilthey.
Wilhelm Dilthey's hermeneutic approach to studying history and culture
critiques historical reason, focusing on the complexity and concreteness of
life. Understanding is not merely subjective but mediated through human
expressions and practices, providing more than just scientific access to
objects. Dilthey's phenomenological descriptions show how historical life is
both about and matters to the individual in its relational context.
The human sciences aim for objectivity, universality, and truth, linking lived
experiences with social-historical structures. Schleiermacher and Dilthey focus
on the individuality, personality, style, and sensibility of the author in
their historical context. Their thought has been retrospectively designated as
"hermeneutical" owing to their interest in associated issues of sense
and meaning, context and historicity, understanding and interpretation, and in
the communicative and explicative dimensions of human life and inquiry.
Twentieth-century hermeneutics, beginning with Heidegger's critical reception
of Dilthey in the 1920s, emphasizes not only the linguistic character of
thought and the disclosive power of language but also its reversals,
limitations, and breakdowns. Interpretation is aimed at the individual and the
singular, as well as the context and the whole in their relational
interdependence. The hermeneutical circle occurs through both contextualization
and individuation, and is provisional and can always begin anew as more is
learned about the individual and the context.
Self-understanding is a complex and questionable concept, as the individual
does not have direct or unmediated self-knowledge. Meaning is inevitably of
"diverse provenance," or pluralistic, and involves a multiplicity of
elements and sources that entail addressing and researching the text, author,
context, and truth claims of a work to interpret and evaluate it.
Thursday, 20 June 2024
Eric Sean Nelson, "Hermeneutics: Schleiermacher and Dilthey" (Summary)
Friday, 17 May 2024
Hermeneutics and Aesthetics
Hermeneutics is a
theory of interpretation and understanding that has roots in Biblical exegesis
and German romanticism. It emerged as a significant branch of contemporary
continental philosophy primarily through the work of Hans-Georg Gadamer, a
philosophical heir to Heidegger. Gadamer's hermeneutics is relevant for
aesthetics in two ways: first, in his 1960 magnum opus Truth and Method, he
uses art and aesthetic experience as examples to defend the kind of
understanding appropriate to the human sciences from methodological scientism
and to develop a general theory of hermeneutics.
Gadamer's general approach to hermeneutics seeks to defend the human sciences
from reduction to the kind of methodology appropriate for the natural sciences.
He argues that the human sciences aim at understanding works (theoretical or
literary texts, artworks, and other cultural products) which themselves cannot
be understood to be entirely separate from the one who seeks to understand.
Instead, both are inscribed within a common horizon of tradition. Tradition
must not be understood in the static sense of conserving what already exists
but rather as a transmission through which works from a world different to the
one we inhabit are passed down to us. Understanding becomes something like a
translation, with the aim being a fusion of horizons of the world of the work
and the world we inhabit.
In later essays and Gadamer's more explicit 'aesthetics', we continue to see
Heidegger's influence and several significant differences. Gadamer seeks to
challenge and overcome what has been called aesthetics in modern philosophy for
different reasons and with a different aim in mind. He objects to Kant's thesis
of the disinterested nature of aesthetic experience, insisting that such
experience brings a cognitive content which connects artworks with our
understanding of other features of the world and other types of experience,
including our interests. Gadamer believes that modern philosophical aesthetics
should be overcome by being absorbed into hermeneutics.
In 'The Relevance of the Beautiful,' Gadamer uses his hermeneutic approach to
understand the nature of artwork, particularly in relation to trans-historical
works. He proposes that art can be understood through the anthropological basis
of our experience of art, which he develops through three key ideas: play,
symbol, and festival.
Play is an intentional activity involving repetition without any real purpose
or goal, and it implies that there is no real separation between the work
itself and the receiver. This activity constitutes the work and brings its
different aspects together through the synthetic activity of interpretation,
constituting the unity of the work. This understanding challenges the modern
aesthetic tradition, which maintains a distinction between the subject and
object in aesthetic experience.
Gadamer uses the notion of the symbol to explain the way in which an artwork
should be thought to be meaningful. He wants to underline the cognitive
dimension of artworks, their connections to our interests and involvements,
while objecting to Hegel's idealist account of artworks, which reduces them
entirely to conceptual content. Gadamer takes inspiration from Heidegger's idea
that every revealing is also a concealing, so that every artwork always
maintains something concealed within it which resists the current
interpretation.
The symbol expresses the way that an artwork can have a meaning that is
cognitive and quasi-linguistic yet excessive and inexhaustible. Language stands
as a paragon for all experience of meaning, so even apparently non-linguistic
experiences such as encounters with artworks must be understood according to a
linguistic model. Understanding a work of art is an interminable affair
involving repeated encounters and acts of interpretation.
Festival reveals something about the temporal character of the artwork and its
affinity with human community. Like the experience of a festival or holiday,
the artwork invites us into an experience of time which differs from the
quantitative, calculative experience of time we have when engaged in work (and
similar everyday activities). Gadamer calls this 'fulfilled' or 'autonomous'
time, which has a certain unity and cannot be dissolved into separate moments.
Art, Gadamer proposes, can be experienced in a way that does not appeal to any
particular social class but unites people in sharing the same kind of
experience. While hermeneutics has been criticized for its emphasis on
tradition and community, it must be emphasized that Gadamer sees both in terms
of openness and transformation.
Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...
-
The concept of "collective memory" encompasses a broad range of phenomena, including rituals, traditions, myths, historical events...
-
, first published in 1844 under the pseudonym Vigilius Haufniensis, is a profound exploration of the human condition, addressing the natur...
-
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...