The evolution of
capitalism in the twenty-first century confirms the hypotheses laid out by Karl
Marx in the Grundrisse regarding automation, the evolution of the economic
function of knowledge, and the corresponding transformations of value. However,
decisive concepts were lacking in 1857 and until Engels' death, leading to the
informational and computational transformations of technology dominating
today's fixed capital. Capitalism is an epistēmē, materialized by the fixed
capital of the reticulated apparatus of production that capitalism has become.
This epistēmē hegemonically reconfigures every instrument of calculation,
including statistics, measurement, simulation, modeling, observation,
production, logistics, mobility, orientation, bibliometrics, scientometrics,
marketing, and lifelogging. Information is the 'allagmatic' operator of this
epistēmē, via computational technology that is perfectly homogenous with
capitalism.
The cognitivist anti-epistēmē develops only by installing a process of
generalized proletarianization. The correlationist mythology of 'big data' is a
prime example of how ideology is being reshaped through the cognitivist
paradigm and marketing. The anti-epistēmē of absolute non-knowledge concretely
ties the latter to entropy, which leads to the collapse of wage labor and the
destruction of knowledge.
Capitalism is confronted with the contradiction and entropic contraction that
its computational development contains and continuously intensifies as a
chaotic phase. A leap beyond this entropic situation is required to open up a
new era, the 'Neganthropocene', which requires a complete redefinition of the
relations between epistēmē and tekhnē, and the transformation of tekhnē into
industrial technology.
The critique of computational proletarianization's absolute non-knowledge must
be based on a critique of information theory, which has always defined information
as a calculable signal. This conception of knowledge dissolves knowledge as it
is irreducible to calculation. Knowledge is a generator of improbable,
incalculable bifurcations, which is possible only in a universe in
concrescence, where life creates localities that defer the rise of entropy qua
increase of disorder. The struggle against anthropy must become the object of a
neganthropology, based on rethinking the concepts of entropy, negentropy, and
anti-entropy starting from the exosomatic perspective developed by Alfred Lotka
in 1945. Overcoming the anthropic eschatological tendencies of computational,
reticular capitalism requires the reconstitution of an epistēmē that would
generate new forms of knowledge characteristic of neganthropology, constituting
a set of therapeutic prescriptions and economic arrangements of new knowledge
that aim to socialize the pharmaka that are mechanical, analogical, and digital
tertiary retentions integrated by platform capitalism.
Digital becoming is a recent stage of gramatization that began in 1993 with the
opening of the World Wide Web. This new associated milieu has two contradictory
tendencies: contributory practices, which break with the structural and
sequential opposition between design, production, and consumption, and
technogeographic associated milieu, which reduces activities to an information
chain capable of being treated algorithmically at near light speed. This
process inverts the processes described in the preceding point as contributing
practices.
The new pharmakon, the organization of fixed capital, becomes more complex and
opaque as a large part of its apparatus comes to be privatized in the form of
consumer items like smartphones. The Entropocene consists of planetary
exorganisms that exist on the functional scale of the biosphere, and the
pharmacological duplicity of fixed capital has become highly flexible and
plastic.
The pharmakon is required by knowledge insofar as the latter must be
exteriorized and spatialized through the work of a différance. This différance
is noetic, mental, and temporal flows and fluxes, composed of primary and
secondary retentions and protentions, are exteriorized, spatialized, and
organized upstream and downstream of the process of interiorization in which
knowledge consists.
if capitalism is possible, particularly in its industrial form, it must be able
to adapt to the new pharmakon and the emergence of new forms of living labor.
Stiegler discusses the concept of cognitive capitalism, which aims to overcome
the Entropocene by transforming economic functions through computational
technologies. This process is based on four types of tertiary retentions:
literal, mechanical, analog, and digital. The tertiarization of primary and
secondary retentions leads to proletarianization, which destroys knowledge and
transforms it into fixed capital. Cognitive capitalism bears these realities
simultaneously, as digital tertiary retention constitutes the epistēmē of
capital and capital as epistēmē. This digital tertiary retention is an
anti-epistēmē, as it destroys knowledge and constitutes the most advanced stage
of capitalism. However, the digital tertiary retention developed by capital is
a pharmakon, with the potential to completely invert this state of fact through
the establishment of a new state of economic law. This law is not required for
social justice concerns but for the establishment of a new economic rationality
that must lead to a revalorization of work and a revaluation of value. The text
concludes by elaborating three points that open up a new economic perspective,
not an exit from capitalism but an opening of another path within the
Entropocene. This path is the Neganthropocene as a revolutionary project,
prescribing terms for Chinese strategic policy in terms of Internet Plus,
generalized automation, smart cities, and neganthropic industries within an
economy of contribution founded on transitional investment towards the
Neganthropocene.
Stiegler discusses the power of the negative, the proletariat, and the
dialectic of master, Herren, and slave, arguing that these issues are
misinterpreted by Marx and Marxism. The Knecht, who develops knowledge beyond
the master, cannot be both a proletarian and a slave. Instead, the bourgeois
form the bourgeoisie, which engenders industrial revolutions and the
bourgeoisie as the revolutionary class. The author proposes
de-proletarianization through contributory inversion, a quasicausal
appropriation of the play of literal, mechanical, analogical, and digital
hypomnesic tertiary retentions. This is a question of constituting a new age of
noesis, which is the process of exosomatization of the functions and faculties
of reason.
Organizing an economy based on de-proletarianization and contribution requires
redeveloping data and network architectures that currently constitute platform
capitalism. This requires analyzing Adam Smith, Andrew Ure, and Marx in terms
of Alfred Lotka's perspective and redefining value to invest in the
Neganthropocene on the basis of a new theory of knowledge. This involves
reconstructing the architecture of academic organologies and focusing on the
neganthropy of exosomatic organs.
The question of fixed capital and the general intellect in Marx's work is not
adequately based on documentation or research due to his ignorance of tertiary
retention. This leads him to a regression compared to his positions in The
German Ideology. The question is not the power of the negative that the
proletariat would embody, but the power of the positive that the pharmakon
would contain as the possibility of a reversal opening up the formation of a
communist economy. This is a question not of the power of the negative but of
the inversion of the potentialities of fixed capital generating an opportunity
for de-proletarianization. Cognitive capitalism requires and initiates a
revolutionary movement of de-proletarianization, but it is not claimed as the
objective of a new state of law. The epistēmē that is capitalism today is
negative and constitutes an absolute non-knowledge, engendering the Entropocene
qua Trumpocene. To de-proletarianize means to re-establish knowledge, which is
always limited, multiple, distributed, and impure due to its neganthropological
potentials.
Monday, 13 May 2024
Bernard Stiegler's "Capitalism as Episteme and Entropocene" (Summary)
Sunday, 12 May 2024
Bernard Stiegler, "The Organology of Dreams and Arche Cinema" (Summary)
Arche-cinema is the
projection of consciousness, with dreams being the primary form. This
projection is a montage, with tertiary retentions forming the fabric and
supporting the cutting room. The transindividual is formed through circuits of transindividuation,
which compromise between diachronic traumatypes and synchronic stereotypes. The
transindividual can metastabilize itself only through tertiary retentions,
technical supports of various kinds. Technical objects, such as cave paintings,
form the third memory of technical and noetic life, beyond the common genetic
memory of the human species and the epigenetic memory belonging to each
individual human.
The appearance of hypomnesic tertiary retentions results in new regimes of
individuation through the play of primary and secondary retentions and
protentions in which attention consists. This leads to new attentional forms,
such as the analogue tertiary retention in music and cinema. Tertiary
retentions play a role in the selection of primary retentions and protentions,
and this play is overdetermined by tertiary retentions as organological
conditions of repetition.
The author discusses the concept of tertiary retention, which is irreducibly
pharmacological and can lead to short-circuits in the play of psychic secondary
retentions. Literal tertiary retention, analogue tertiary retention, and
digital tertiary retention all constitute positive pharmacological
possibilities, generating new attentional forms and forming therapeutic
practices from those pharmaka.
The author distinguishes between epochs, particularly the epoch of
grammatization, which allowed mental temporal contents into spatial forms. This
possibility appeared during the Upper Palaeolithic and led to the emergence of
cinema, as described by archaeologist Marc Azéma.
Arche-cinema, the omnitemporal conditions in which the technical form of life,
which is also the noetic and oneiric form of life, rests on processes of
projection through montages of primary, secondary, and tertiary retention and
protention, was concretized in the form of retentional systems projecting and
spatializing movement in prehistoric caves. This led to the development of
movie theatres and movie screens as we know them today.
The advent of digital tertiary retention in the history of cinema is at stake
with the advent of digital tertiary retention. The history of the supplement,
which implements this arche-cinema, is what is concretized during the course of
organo-genesis, and notably as what we now refer to as "cinema." In
2012, we find ourselves living in the epoch of digital tertiary retention,
which makes possible a cinema without film.
In all these cases, re-temporalization constitutes a projection in the course
of which readers, listeners, and spectators project their own secondary
protentions and retentions into the textual, musical, or cinematic flux, and
select primary retentions, which then generate primary protentions. Cinema is
seen as a pharmakon, acting as a disease that can either reinforce stereotypes
held by the public or put to work its traumatypes.
Cinema is viewed by Adorno and Horkheimer as a functional element of a system
aiming to disseminate ideology and stimulate consumer behavior. This view is
similar to the French New Wave, which saw cinema as a pharmakon rather than a
poison. Cinematic art struggles against the disease of cinema with the means of
cinema, which is that of desire or dreams. A film is a kind of dream with a
common daytime dream, manifesting a desire that we imagine to be that of a
public, not just that of a filmmaker.
Adorno and Horkheimer argue that cinema is this process of disindividuation,
which is the drama of cinema and confronted by great directors like Federico
Fellini. Fellini's work examines the relation between cinema and dream, drawing
parallels between the dream and the nightmare brought by Berlusconi to Italy
and Italian cinema. The age of digital tertiary retention has significantly
changed the relationship between moving images and sound, making them an everyday
practice for everyone. This transformation is comparable to the transition from
hieroglyphic writing to alphabetical writing. Dreams are now a part of this
transformation, as they are a moment within a noetic sensorimotor loop that
internalizes an artefactual retentional organization. This structure generates
stereotypes and destroys the libido, which decomposes into the drives.
The consumerist capitalist economy, initially cinematic and then televisual,
destroys the libido, leading to cinematic dreams becoming drive-based
nightmares, such as horror movies. This transformation affects our
psychological, political, economic, and industrial dreams, as YouTube creates
open studios for learning, sharing, and creating.
The film industry has been a capitalist stage of the libidinal economy and the
organology of dreams, which are the workshops or studios of this libidinal
economy. Digital tertiary retention establishes a new industrial organology
that poses these problems in new terms, making possible new dreams. The New
Wave of cinema emerged in the late 1950s, with filmmakers and audiences
becoming amateurs and film-lovers.
Intervista explores the concept of dream-taking and the organological
conditions of dreams, arguing that dreams are a kind of waking dream, shaped by
transitional objects and influenced by the organological powers and impotencies
of the individual. The invention of the digital system occurred not because the
analogue system had reached its limits, but because the oneiric being that we are,
which is also the noetic being, is essentially constituted by the co-evolution
of its dreams and technics.
Saturday, 11 May 2024
Bernard Stiegler's "The Anthropocene and Neganthropology" (Summary)
• Stiegler argues that humans are noetic beings who weave psychic secondary retentions on collective secondary retentions.
• Humans individuate themselves by exteriorizing the protentions contained within these retentional funds, hidden as potentials that are concretized and actualized through being transindividuated.
• The Anthropocene era refers to the most recent period of geophysical evolution, where the systemic and toxic character of contemporary organicology comes to light.
• The text questions the meaning of belief when we no longer believe it is possible to change a situation where the 'human factor' is a cosmic element or at least a geo-logical one.
• The data economy has established an industrial and automatized production of protentions, guiding them by remote control or annihilation.
• Stiegler calls for a complete rethinking of the noetic fact, raising questions of practical organology, inventive productions, and a total reinvention of the architecture of the World Wide Web.
• The advent of the thermodynamic machine has led to an epistemic crisis, introducing the question of fire and its pharmacology on both the astrophysical plane and human ecology.
• The organological approach is constitutively situated in time, with its object being becoming and its question being the transformation of becoming into future.
• Digital technology, which completely reconfigures the globalized industrial infrastructure, is the unavoidable path we must follow.
• The Anthropocene is an organological epoch that has generated the organological question itself, which is constituted by its own recognition and the necessity of overcoming itself.
• The question of the trace, of its interiorization and exteriorization, is the first formulation of the pharmacological question.
• The algorithmic governmentality of 24/7 capitalism leads to the formation of artificial crowds, the origin of 'crowd sourcing' or the data economy.
Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...
-
The concept of "collective memory" encompasses a broad range of phenomena, including rituals, traditions, myths, historical events...
-
, first published in 1844 under the pseudonym Vigilius Haufniensis, is a profound exploration of the human condition, addressing the natur...
-
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...