Showing posts with label African Studies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label African Studies. Show all posts

Thursday, 11 January 2024

Stratton's "Contemporary African Literature and the Politics of Gender" (Book Note)

 

 

Florence Stratton's thesis in "Contemporary African Literature and the Politics of Gender" asserts that the "dialogic interaction between men's and women's writings is one of the defining features of the contemporary African literary tradition". Stratton initiates her argument by illustrating the omission of African women's writing from male-produced constructions of African literature. Examining writers from East and West Africa (excluding South Africa), both in English and in translation, she explores how African women writers engage with literature by men and the dominant patriarchal discourse of gender. While acknowledging a theoretical debt to Fredric Jameson's "The Political Unconscious" and Abdul R. JanMohamed's "Manichean Aesthetics," she revises their ideas to incorporate gender considerations.

 

Stratton's book is organized into three sections: "Aspects of the Male Literary Tradition," "Room for Women," and "Men Write Back." In "Aspects of the Male Literary Tradition," she first delves into Chinua Achebe's "Things Fall Apart," highlighting how Achebe, while focused on countering European racism, neglected to address African or European sexism. The following chapter in this section discusses 'The Mother Africa Trope,' identifying the national subject as male, relegating women to an association with Africa and subjecting them to male domination. This trope is traced through various male writers and movements, including Ngugi wa Thiong'o, Okot p'Bitek, Ousmane Sembène, Camara Laye, Nuruddin Farah, Wole Soyinka, and Mongo Bed. The middle section devotes chapters to African women writers Grace Ogot (Kenya), Flora Nwapa (Nigeria), Buchi Emecheta (Nigeria), and Miriama Bâ (Senegal). Each chapter explores how these women's works challenge the male tradition and dominant tropes of womanhood, examining how gender issues influence their production and reception. The final section scrutinizes Ngugi's "Devil on the Cross" and Achebe's "Anthills of the Savannah"  as partially successful attempts to engage in a dialogue with women and "transform the status of women from that of object to that of subject."

"Contemporary African Literature and the Politics of Gender" is a readable, well-argued, thoroughly researched, and balanced feminist work that sheds light on the integral role of women's writing in the African literary tradition and the dominant discourse of gender. Florence Stratton's contribution makes it challenging for critics to continue marginalizing this writing. While acknowledging the book's feminist agenda, it is evident that the work is thoughtful and fair in its approach.

 

The author addresses the limitations inherent in any book attempting to cover all contextual discourses of a text, emphasizing that her primary concern is with gender discourse. She acknowledges the interconnectedness of various discourse systems and the need to understand them in relation to one another. However, there is a concern raised about the book's production primarily for the Western academy. Biodun Jeyifo's observation about the shift of African literary study away from Africa to Europe and America is noted, and while Stratton spent a significant time in African discourses, there is a call for more nuanced considerations of the specificity of Western and postcolonial feminisms.

 

Stratton's effort to integrate women's writing into the African literary tradition is commendable, although there is a suggestion that she might overlook the potential risk of interpreting African women's resistance through a Western feminist lens. The need for more work on distinguishing the specificities of Western and postcolonial feminisms is highlighted.

 

While the book successfully discusses a few women writers in detail, there is a desire for more attention to writers like Ama Ata Aidoo, who holds a significant position in African literature and was recognized with a Commonwealth Writers Prize in 1992. Despite minor quibbles, Stratton's work has undeniably solidified the critical position of African women's writing and is predicted to reshape the landscape of African studies.

Thursday, 14 December 2023

Kobena Mercer, "Welcome to the Jungle: New Positions in Black Cultural Studies" (Book Note)

 


In his collected essays, "Welcome to the Jungle," Mercer articulates the nuances of what some of the "new positions" in black cultural studies might convey. Mercer adopts an unsentimental approach to social categories such as race, class, sexuality, and gender. Rather than dismissing their importance, he seeks to move beyond the confines of identity politics. Mercer advocates for a shift towards the more ambivalent and ambiguous terrain of multiple points of identification. Drawing a crucial distinction between identity and identification, he emphasizes the latter as a means to understand how political actions and practices are not rigidly tied to specific identities. Mercer challenges the assumption that a black body is inherently the locus of anti-racist politics, or that female bodies inherently represent feminism, and similarly, the gay body queer politics. He highlights that political identifications can traverse social categories, making it impossible to predict an individual's politics based solely on their identity.

 

"Welcome to the Jungle" poses probing questions about black cultural politics, centering its primary focus on issues of hybridity and creolization. Mercer engages both within and in opposition to cultural studies, particularly in essays like "Welcome to the Jungle: Identity and Diversity in Postmodern Politics" and "'1968': Periodizing Politics and Identity." He advocates for an understanding of identity as continuously unstable, and it is within this context of identity instability that he subjects political strategies and actions to scrutiny through the lens of representational practices.

 

Representational strategies and practices play a crucial role in highlighting the political significance of identity, providing artists, writers, filmmakers, and others with avenues to foster diverse and multiple identifications, transcending the constraints of social bodies. Mercer's work robustly challenges the essentialisms inherent in identity politics while remaining mindful of the historical importance of identity-based movements like the American civil rights movement, feminism, gay and lesbian liberation, and British anti-racism. Despite recognizing the contributions of these movements, Mercer calls for a broader political vision, particularly in the contemporary postmodern moment marked by the erosion of liberatory and emancipatory narratives.

 

Within the realm of art, especially in photography, fine art, and film, Mercer makes a compelling case for delving into the politics of identity and identifications. In his essay "Black Art and the Burden of Representation," he contends that the scarcity of spaces for black artists, writers, and filmmakers to exhibit their work places an undue burden on each piece and artist to represent and speak on behalf of the Black community. Mercer challenges the notion that black artists, appearing one at a time in the public eye, should bear the responsibility of representing an entire community. Instead, he advocates for a more nuanced approach in cultural politics, rejecting the tendency to view these artists as mere representatives and emphasizing the need for a complex critique. This more intricate approach involves not condemning artists for perceived failures in representing a specific imagined community but encouraging critiques that facilitate the proliferation of various representations of diverse imagined communities.

 

Mercer acknowledges the dual nature of the issue: firstly, the conservatism of a particular artist may raise questions about the political messages conveyed by their work. However, the second criterion becomes crucial—creating a space for the proliferation of other works with different narratives, enriching the cultural landscape of representations. Mercer's insightful analysis of Isaac Julien's films underscores their disruption of heteronormative assertions of blackness, introducing diverse perspectives into cultural artifacts and practices.

 

In his essays on black masculinities, particularly those examining Robert Mapplethorpe's work, Mercer offers illuminating insights. In "Imagining the Black Man’s Sex," he critiques Mapplethorpe's photographs of black male sexuality, highlighting the objectification of various stereotypes. Mercer questions the central focus on the penis and the headless black models. However, in a bold re-reading in "Skin Head Sex Thing: Racial Difference and the Homoerotic Imaginary," Mercer reconsiders his earlier analysis, exploring his own homoerotic response to the photographs. Through a complex and shifting analysis, he establishes an ambivalent relationship with the images, suggesting that seeing the black male nudes as the beginning of a subversive deconstruction opens up new possibilities. Mercer's ability to recognize the polyvocal quality of Mapplethorpe's work allows him to revise his position, accounting for biographical and autobiographical dimensions without resorting to a simplistic experiential mode.

 

Mercer challenges simplistic politics of experience and commonality in his essays, emphasizing the urgency of constituting a politics of liberation and emancipation amidst the collapse of such narratives. He avoids easy universalist statements about transnational blackness, arguing for dialogism that acknowledges the plural and heterogeneous nature of black identities. Mercer contends that critical dialogism questions the monologic exclusivity underlying dominant versions of national identity, emphasizing the potential for diasporic black peoples to make identifications across borders while remaining mindful of the ways in which the local organizes experience.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wednesday, 22 November 2023

Brent Hayes Edwards, " The Practice of Diaspora" (Book Note)

 


While the trans-Atlantic connections between Africa, Europe, and the Americas have long been a subject of study, the recent resurgence in interest, particularly among younger scholars, can be largely attributed to the impact of Paul Gilroy's seminal work, "The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double-Consciousness" (1993). As a sociologist trained in cultural studies, Gilroy argued for a diasporic model of cultural connection to comprehend the similarities and differences among black communities around the Atlantic. His work proposed the concept of "counter-modernity," challenging Western humanism and its institutions. While Gilroy's argument was both exciting and frustrating, particularly for its lack of empirical engagement, it played a pivotal role in reshaping the history of the Atlantic world.

 

"The Practice of Diaspora" by Brent Hayes Edwards situates itself between the theoretical and empirical approaches. Edwards, a literary scholar, focuses on contemporary cultural debates with a specific historical goal: to recover and analyze the trans-Atlantic relationships that developed among black intellectuals during the interwar period. Unlike Gilroy, Edwards adopts a more chronologically focused and empirically grounded approach, emphasizing Paris and the Francophone world. His methodology emphasizes language, translation, and the role of literary work in creating linkages and a common black sensibility in the Atlantic world, using sources such as journals, anthologies, and book prefaces to demonstrate that black internationalism was a tangible outcome of correspondence, translation, and other written practices.

 

In Chapter 1, Edwards discusses his sources and method, highlighting his commitment to "anti-abstractionist uses of diaspora" and introducing the notion of "ddcalage" to interpret how diaspora functions, emphasizing the disjuncture of time and distance inherent in any understanding of diaspora. Chapter 2 explores the correspondence between Rend Maran, the Martinican poet, and Alain Locke, the African-American writer and critic. Their relationship, sparked by Maran's influential work "Batouala," reveals the complexities of being black, a French citizen, and a colonial administrator in Africa. Chapter 3 delves into the life of Paulette Nardal, a Martinican in Paris who founded the bilingual journal "La Revue du monde noir" and hosted a weekly salon for black university students and visiting writers from Harlem, adding a significant gender dimension to Edwards's historical analysis.

 

In Chapter 4, the focus shifts to a detailed exploration of a single text, Claude McKay's novel "Banjo" (1929). Set in the port city of Marseilles and depicting black workers and drifters, Edwards discusses the novel's significance in creating a view of vagabond internationalism. Despite its promise of a black cosmopolitanism from below, this vision remains unfulfilled. Chapter 5 extends the proletarian theme by examining the collaboration between George Padmore and Tiemoko Garan Kouyaté through their connections with the Soviet Comintern. This final chapter intertwines black internationalism, anticolonialism, and Marxist-Leninism.

 

Kouyaté, born in Segu, Mali, emerges as a fascinating figure, expressing his wish to C. L. R. James that "Trotsky was a black man." Kouyaté's story becomes an allegory for activist-intellectuals, characterized by piercing ideas and imaginative effort but lacking institutional support. Edwards poignantly notes the fragility of connections, such as a momentary possibility of collaboration between Kouyaté and W. E. B. Du Bois that remains unrealized.

 

The detailed insight and verve that Edwards brings to this history reveal a conceptual and empirical richness uncommon in similar studies. While familiar figures like Du Bois, James, and Garvey make appearances, Edwards's committed exploration of lesser-known figures like Maran, Nardal, and Kouyaté adds excitement to the study. Even figures like Nguyen Ai Quoc (later Ho Chi Minh) are present through their relationships with Lamine, Senghor, and others in the Union Intercoloniale.

 

Some historians may have reservations about "The Practice of Diaspora." It reads more like a series of essays than a sequence of chronological chapters, with occasional digressions into conceptual discussions that might feel dense with names and jargon. Additionally, the concept of "décalage," while causal, is not fully developed as a historical theory. The focus remains on "publication" history rather than "event" history, and a broader pattern beyond these tenuous links may not fully materialize.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Henry Louis Gates Jr. (ed), Black Literature and Literary Theory" (Book Note)

 


The primary purpose of literary criticism is to shed light on works of art, and the literature of the African diaspora has garnered attention from a diverse array of literary critics representing various critical perspectives. Critical theories spanning Formalism, Marxism, Psychoanalysis, and Structuralism have all contributed to the examination of these literatures. A significant contemporary challenge facing critics of Black literature is the formulation of a critical theory rooted in black culture. Influential artists like Chinua Achebe, Mongo Beti, Ngugi Wa Thiong'o, Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston, Richard Wright, Toni Morrison, and George Lamming have been profoundly shaped by their cultural backgrounds. Consequently, valid interpretations of their works must be sensitive to the cultural milieu from which they emerged.

 

In the introductory essay to "Black Literature & Literary Theory" titled "Criticism in the Jungle," Gates defines "black" as encompassing African, Caribbean, and Afro-American literature. He raises the implicit question of how applicable contemporary literary theory is to the reading of African, Caribbean, and Afro-American literary traditions. The response to this question unfolds in a series of essays by scholar-critics who demonstrate a nuanced understanding of contemporary theories and Afrocentric aesthetic postulations. The collection also, to some extent, addresses the call made during the Black Arts Movement of the 60s for the conceptualization of a critical theory divorced from Western theories.

 

The initial essay by Nigerian writer Wole Soyinka delves into the language of the social critic, critically engaging with Roland Barthes' definitions of langue and parole. Soyinka expresses discontent with critics, such as Gerald Moore and Bernth Lindfors, who have misinterpreted his works. However, the essay leaves the reader without a clear view of the applicability of Barthes' theory to "black letters." In contrast, James Snead's "Repetition as a Figure of Black Culture" emerges as one of the most enlightening contributions in the collection. This essay lends credibility to the advocacy for a theory of interpretation rooted in culture. Snead challenges Hegel's assertion that "black culture simply did not exist in the same sense as European culture did" and discusses the relevance of "repetition" in black culture, emphasizing its pivotal role. Using examples from artists like James Brown and John Coltrane, Snead illustrates how this motif from African music influences contemporary artists such as Toni Morrison, Ishmael Reed, and Leon Forrest in their literary works.

Structuralism has encountered resistance among critics of Black Literature, with the pioneering work of Sunday Anozie, as seen in "Structural Models & African Poetics" (1982) and his essay in "Black Literature and Literary Theory" (pp. 105-125), failing to sway critics toward embracing structuralist poetics. Anthony Appiah's strong rebuttal to Anozie's application of structuralism to African works (pp. 127-150) further elucidates the fundamental suspicions held by critics of Black literature regarding the "applicability" and relevance of this theory within the literary canon. The reluctance to adopt structuralist theories in African and Afro-American criticism stems from the theory itself, which views a work of art as an autonomous system of structures requiring "decodification." Some critics find structuralism to be an escapist approach that lacks social and political commitment.

 

While structuralism has faced skepticism in the realm of Black literature, certain aspects of it, such as intertextuality and studies on myth and folktale by Levi-Strauss and Vladimir Propp, may offer useful insights. Propp's method of breaking down folktales into component parts and analyzing their relation to the whole, as demonstrated in Jay Edwards' essay on the "Structural Analysis of the Afro-American trickster tale" (pp. 80-103), reflects a potential avenue for exploration.

 

The second part of "Black Literature and Literary Theory," titled "Practice," features insightful essays on African-American literature by Bowen, Johnson, Baker, Washington, Wills, Stepto, and Gates. These essays interpret works from the literary canon through various perspectives. Barbara Johnson and Mary Helen Washington, for instance, emphasize the seminal role of the "feminist voice" that has been overlooked by scholars and critics. Their analyses of Zora Neale Hurston's "Their Eyes Were Watching God" and Gwendolyn Brooks' "Maud Martha" underscore the pivotal contributions of these texts to African-American literature. Recent critical studies, such as Mari Evans' "Black Women Writers (1950-1980)," are expected to expand the scope of literary theories applied to Black literature, especially the works of women writers.

The essay that stands out as particularly provocative in "Black Literature and Literary Theory" is authored by Henry Louis Gates Jr., titled "The blackness of blackness: a critique of the sign and the signifying monkey" (pp. 285-321). Carolyn Fowler, in her intriguing introduction to "Black Arts and Black Aesthetics," contends that works in Black literature require new value judgments that acknowledge the cultural artifacts shaping the artistic sensibilities of the writers. In 1973, Stephen Henderson, in his significant essay "The Forms of Things Unknown" (See "Understanding the New Black Poetry," pp. 3-69), formulated a critical theory for reading Black poetry. Gates' essay in the same volume is a pioneering work in a similar direction, proposing a theory of interpretation from "within the black cultural matrix."

 

Gates explores the role of the Signifying Monkey in black culture, identifying it as a trickster figure akin to those in Yoruba mythology, such as Esu-Elegbara in Nigeria and Legba among the Fon of Dahomey. He further explains the Signifying Monkey as the "signifier" wreaking havoc upon the "signified." Gates elucidates Afro-American narrative parody and applies it to the analysis of Ishmael Reed's "Mumbo Jumbo," considering it a "signifying pastiche of the Afro-American narrative tradition." Drawing from diverse sources in black culture, Gates establishes a solid theoretical framework and analyzes the works of major Afro-American writers. He contends that Ellison, for example, is a "Great Signifier" naming things indirectly throughout his works. Ellison engages in parodying Richard Wright's literary structures through repetition and difference.

 

In a detailed analysis of Ishmael Reed's "Mumbo Jumbo," which parodies the Harlem Renaissance, Gates suggests that the work is both about texts and composed of sub-texts, pre-texts, post-texts, and narratives within narratives. Gates' insightful analyses are informed by sociological, linguistic, and historical data from black culture. While "Black Literature and Literary Theory" is a pioneering and provocative text for students of Black literature and contemporary theories, it is noted for a major weakness— the absence of an essay on Afro-Caribbean literature, especially considering Gates' definition of "black" as a metaphor for the African diaspora. Nonetheless, the collection supports the notion that contemporary theories can indeed illuminate works in Black literature, with the most rewarding theories rooted in Black culture.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thursday, 26 October 2023

Basil Davidson's "The Search for Africa" (Book Note)


 

"The Search for Africa" is a collection of eighteen essays written by Davidson between 1953 and 1992, each placed in a contemporary context through updated introductory comments. Throughout these pages, familiar ideological and interpretative viewpoints from Davidson's previous works reappear. This positions him as a prominent voice in understanding Africa, having likely imparted more knowledge about the continent to the West since World War II than any other commentator, while maintaining the respect of Africans.

 

Davidson frames the book against the backdrop of the challenging conditions prevailing in many African societies towards the end of the 20th century. While he acknowledges more stable times in Africa's history, characterized by social order and collective confidence, he traces the descent into the abyss of slavery and colonialism, the optimism of independence, and the subsequent disillusionment as neocolonial legacies persist.

 

The book contends that solutions to contemporary African problems must come from within the continent itself. Davidson emphasizes the importance of understanding Africa's history to derive what he terms "the lessons of internal culture." These lessons can guide Africans towards a better future, free from the ills of political, economic, and cultural imperialism, as well as racial prejudice.

 

The first section of the book, titled "Claims," highlights the accomplishments of past African cultures. It depicts Egyptian pharaonic civilization as an African phenomenon influenced by other African societies. The spread of Islamic culture from northern Africa and its blending with indigenous communities through extensive trade networks is also discussed. The essays demonstrate the achievements of African societies in tropical agriculture, metallurgy, and social organization, attributed to consultative rule and an effective system of checks and balances.

 

However, these achievements were diminished around the 1600s due to the burgeoning slave trade, which altered Europeans' perceptions of their African neighbors. Respect and tolerance were replaced with a belief in the inherent inferiority of Africans. This attitude was further exacerbated during centuries of European technological advancement, causing the non-material accomplishments of Africans to be disregarded. Davidson argues that Africa's path forward involves rediscovering and valuing the successes of indigenous African political experience and implementing them on a broader scale than the current nation-states.

The second section of the book, titled "Antipathies," delves into the colonialist dismantling of African life and intellect. It scrutinizes the inception of apartheid and what Davidson labels as "legalized servitude" in South Africa. Additionally, it explores imperialist oppression in Angola and the Congo.

 

Davidson's observations in 1969 of the burgeoning pluralism in the colony of Northern Rhodesia serve as a precursor to the third part of the book, "Sympathies." This section showcases Davidson's journalistic prowess, particularly in "Voices from the Front," where he recounts his experiences in guerrilla warfare alongside his friend Amilcar Cabral, the revolutionary leader later assassinated by the Portuguese, in the Portuguese colony of Guinea. Davidson's affinity, both physical and ideological, with the liberation movements active across Africa at the time is palpable. His narratives of their struggles are marked by sympathy and emotional resonance.

 

In the fourth part, "Debates," the focus shifts to a period closer to the present. Davidson attributes much of Africa's current turmoil to the enduring legacy of colonialism, which ingrained autocratic, arbitrary, and oppressive governance, entrenched privilege, and fostered centralized administration that failed to acknowledge the diverse cultural tapestry of the population. The decolonization process and transition to independence were often tumultuous, at times even culminating in the calculated institutionalization of colonial chaos. This manifested in unfavorable trade agreements and the creation of crises in food production, urban development, and industrial investment. In a 1976 essay, Davidson proposes a remedy to this dire situation—a reinvigoration of African history after the prolonged period of colonial estrangement. He advocates for a shift of power from centralized authority to local self-governance, along with the promotion of regional associations based on traditional ethnic lines.

 

The book culminates emphatically in the final section, "Arguments," where Davidson presents two bold perspectives that encapsulate his overarching agenda. Firstly, he underscores that the ancient Greeks, renowned for their recognition and respect of the achievements of pharaonic Egypt, also acknowledged that pharaonic culture had deep-rooted origins in inner Africa. This alignment of ancient Greek historical analysis with Davidson's own viewpoint challenges the longstanding Western bias against attributing value to African civilizations, if they were acknowledged at all. Secondly, in "The Curse of Columbus" Davidson contends that Christopher Columbus, celebrated fervently in the 500th anniversary year, was, in truth, the architect of the transatlantic slave trade. It was through his endeavors that much of the Western world ultimately adopted the notion of African inferiority to justify their enslavement. Davidson regards this readiness of Europeans to accept moral degradation in exchange for economic gain and political dominion as a grievous moral failing that should weigh heavily on the Western conscience.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Annie Coombes' "Reinventing Africa" (Book Note)


 

Annie Coombes' book, "Reinventing Africa: Museums, Material Culture and Popular Imagination in Late Victorian and Edwardian England," critically examines the evolution of African studies, urging a shift away from entrenched Eurocentric perspectives. As both institutions and art councils endeavor to reassess the essence of African studies, questions inevitably arise about the origins of the prevailing mindset and the role played by museums and academics in perpetuating, rather than dispelling, colonial myths.

 

Coombes' exploration is thorough and meticulous. She contends that in late Victorian and Edwardian England, African objects were initially viewed as mere curiosities. However, private merchants, government bodies, missionary organizations, museums, and academic institutions purposefully redefined these objects, evaluating them based on their 'Aesthetic' attributes. This reevaluation was part of a deliberate effort to influence the British middle and working classes, ultimately justifying behaviors that might otherwise have raised ethical concerns. Coombes further delves into the contemporaneous materials of this era, providing insight into the social transformations in England and their impact on various groups with vested interests in shaping perceptions of Africa and Africans.

 

Coombes' introductory remarks underscore a critical gap in the exploration of the relationship between anthropology's public image and academic discourse during the period of 1890-1913. She emphasizes the disconnect between the anthropological theories disseminated in public spaces, particularly through museums, and those produced for circulation within the burgeoning academic community. Coombes asserts that this disparity complicates the use of ethnographic collections as indicators of the latest developments in anthropological thought, emphasizing instead that these collections represent the convergence of state, institutional, and professional politics and policies during this period.

 

To illustrate this point, Coombes commences with the well-known history of the Benin "punitive expedition" of 1897. She unpacks the socioeconomic motivations behind the raid and examines early critiques of it, some of which were published shortly after the expedition. Coombes then turns her attention to the prized "booty" of the raid—the numerous Benin bronzes and ivories. Initially, these objects were showered with attention, with colonial administrators and companies aiming to use them as tangible evidence of Benin's "savagery," thus justifying their military campaign. Simultaneously, certain scholars used the art to substantiate the 'degeneration' theory about Benin culture, arguing that the casting techniques at the time of the raid were inferior to those used for earlier objects. While some scholars, like Ling-Roth, highlighted the merits of the Benin castings, others attributed the fineness of the craftsmanship to European intervention or even an Egyptian origin.

 

Coombes elucidates how the theory of cultural degeneracy, in vogue at the time, was imposed on the Benin material to provide additional "evidence" for the case of cultural decline. This theory posited that most non-Western civilizations had experienced a cultural zenith at some point, only to face a steady decline. The abstraction in design elements was interpreted as an inability to accurately replicate ancient motifs. The Benin material was thus redefined as a form of "art" and an exemplar of savagery that only colonialism could rectify. Crucially, the work was labeled as "degenerate," leading to the endorsement of moral and ethical views validated by scientific discourse.

 

In the subsequent sections of the book, Coombes sheds light on the power of 'Spectacles,' which resembled large-scale world's fair exhibitions showcasing various parts of the empire, including displays of African material as trophies. Coombes underscores that these spectacles were not only racist but also sexist, often portraying women as mere possessions of their "savage" husbands. Africa underwent a redefinition—from a land of 'savages' requiring military intervention for redemption to a dark and enigmatic continent, rife with peculiar rituals and unusual customs. This revised perception of Africa could, of course, be "improved" with the assistance of colonial intervention, spurred by both public interest and private interest groups seeking to capitalize on the growing fascination with all things African.

 

Coombes then shifts her focus to the emerging museums of the time—the Horniman, the Pitt-Rivers, and the Mayer museums. She demonstrates how these ethnographic institutions increasingly paid attention to what were previously regarded as mere curiosities. These objects, though not yet classified as "art," were now considered indicative of the anthropological viewpoints advocated by the museum directors, such as degenerationist and diffusionist theories. Rebranded as 'craft,' these African art objects were once again redefined, this time as educational tools for illuminating the 'evolution' of cultures.

Coombes delves into a critical examination of the prevailing perspectives on Africa during a specific period and in a distinct context. She calls attention to the transformation in societal and moral norms that occurred during the Edwardian era, challenging established Victorian paradigms. Coombes emphasizes the shifts in the social and political landscape of African colonies, brought about in part by the colonial process itself, which led to new challenges for the British state. These shifts included the emergence of an educated elite and the rise of small radical presses that voiced demands and exchanged ideas with West African newspapers. Protests against colonial administrations were also gaining traction within the colonies, impacting British society, either directly or indirectly.

 

While Coombes's work is generally direct and balanced, occasional confusion arises, particularly in the interchange of the Kuba and the Luba groups when describing objects in a photograph. This attention to detail, which Coombes champions throughout the text, should ideally extend to the accurate representation of material objects.

 

Coombes also questions the French approach to archaeological work in Tunis, suggesting that their efforts were driven by a desire to assert themselves as the discoverers and guardians of Tunisian heritage and history. She contends that the French saw it as their duty to preserve this historical memory, considering it neglected by the Tunisian people. However, it's worth noting that the interests of modern Tunisians may not have aligned with the preservation of ancient Pagan sites. Coombes also draws a parallel with the British efforts in India to preserve significant monuments, underscoring the complexity of colonial endeavors.

 

One potential critique lies in the hindsight with which we view historical events. Coombes acknowledges that anthropometry, though criticized in her work, was a legitimate form of physical study during the period in question. She suggests that caution and a nuanced perspective might be warranted when evaluating these practices in their historical context.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Friday, 13 October 2023

ME Chamberlin's "The Scramble for Africa" (Book Note)




The scramble for Africa stands as an unequivocal watershed moment in world history, marking the onset of profound transformations for Africans. This text commences with an introductory chapter delving into the African context. It provides succinct overviews of various regions in Africa and introduces key empires and trade networks from the precolonial era. This chapter, though eminently readable and logically structured, carries a distinctly 1970s nationalist fervor in its tone. The author consistently emphasizes that Africa possesses a rich history, countering the earlier Eurocentric notion that it lacked a historical narrative of its own. The subsequent chapter delves into the Victorian perception of Africa. This chapter excels in elucidating factors such as slavery, technological advancements, scientific racism, and humanitarianism that influenced England's perception of Africa. The author contends that these elements impacted both public and private perspectives of Africa, often intertwining them. However, a notable limitation is the exclusive focus on Victorian England. While these influences undoubtedly extended to other colonial powers in Western Europe, the reader must infer such thematic assumptions. The text doesn't offer insight into how these themes resonated in other parts of Western Europe or how factors like nationalism or denominationalism may have shaped these perceptions. This chapter's coverage embodies two interconnected shortcomings that persist throughout the text.

 

The book's title is somewhat misleading. It doesn't thoroughly examine the entirety of the scramble for Africa, but rather centers on the British scramble. While understanding the British role in this period is crucial, the title suggests a broader scope than the text delivers, a common trait in works on colonial Africa. Readers expecting a discussion on a continental scale may find themselves somewhat disappointed. However, for those seeking insights into the British role, this book serves as an excellent introduction.

 

The British are the only historical actors portrayed in a multi-dimensional manner. The French, Germans, and Portuguese are mentioned in passive roles, occasionally frustrating British ambitions or accepting established boundaries. Africans are similarly depicted as reactive figures, almost ethereal in their passivity, maneuvering around the active British. While it's fitting that Africans are frequently mentioned, there's a clear need to delve into African agency, interests, and strategies in a more nuanced manner.

 

Despite these drawbacks, the text boasts commendable attributes. The majority of the content entails an analysis of regional case studies concerning British African imperialism in Egypt, West Africa, East Africa, South Africa, and the Sudan. With the exception of British territories in the Horn of Africa, the case studies collectively narrate the acquisition of all parts of British Africa, with a relatively brief mention of southern Africa beyond the colony of South Africa. The author effectively illustrates the somewhat haphazard nature of British imperialism in Africa, which often lacked a cohesive overarching strategy, akin to British decolonization strategies in later decades. This theme is reiterated in the conclusion. A notable strength lies in the author's balanced portrayal of various British actors, whether they be policy-makers, investors, ardent nationalists, or the British public. The reader gains an appreciation for the diverse interests involved in the British pursuit of African territories.

 

Two additional strengths pertain specifically to instructors of world history. The inclusion of twenty-seven primary documents at the end of the text, referenced within the narrative, contextualizes these documents for the reader. Furthermore, the concluding chapter provides a comprehensive summary of significant theoretical works on the "new imperialism," including contributions from Hobson, Lenin, and Robinson and Gallagher, among others. Chamberlain adeptly outlines the shift from earlier mono-causal explanations to more multi-causal interpretations in recent decades. This historiographical survey could greatly benefit world history teachers.

 

From a theoretical standpoint, the most significant strength lies in Chamberlain's challenge to postcolonial and postmodern theories. These theories have made vital contributions by uncovering and amplifying the voices of indigenous agents, thereby contesting earlier colonial narratives rooted in Eurocentrism. However, in their zeal to vanquish Eurocentrism, postcolonial writers often vilify all things Western and romanticize all things indigenous. Chamberlain reminds us that history is more complex. Heroes and villains emerge in all times and places. The author frequently highlights internal British critics of imperialism, underscoring that their voices were few and often ineffectual. Nevertheless, their existence demonstrates that the scramble was a morally intricate affair, far more complex than either Eurocentrism or postcolonialism can convey. However, to further advance this theoretical point, incorporating more perspectives on African agency, wherever Africans stood in their shifting relationship to colonialism, is essential. Chamberlain applies this nuanced understanding primarily to the British, yet Africans, too, were entangled in intricate and evolving relationships with colonialism. This aspect warrants more attention in the narrative.

 

 

 

 

  

Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||

  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...