Showing posts with label Postmodern. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Postmodern. Show all posts

Tuesday, 23 April 2024

Lyotard's "Defining the Postmodern" (Summary)

 

 Lyotard highlights certain issues regarding the term 'postmodern'. Rather than seeking to conclude the debate, his intention is to initiate and nurture it, steering clear of specific confusions and ambiguities wherever feasible, thus enabling its organic development.

 

The term 'postmodern' brings up several debates, and Lyotard discusses three of them. First, there's a debate between postmodernism and modernism, especially in architecture from 1910 to 1945. Some say there's a clear break between them. For example, Paolo Portoghesi talks about a shift away from traditional geometric styles like those in De Stijl. Another architect, Victorio Grigotti, thinks the main difference is that postmodern architecture doesn't focus on big societal changes anymore. Instead, it works on smaller-scale projects and doesn't aim to completely redesign everything. This opens up new possibilities for architecture.

In this perspective, there's no longer a grand vision of progress and freedom for postmodern people, including architects. The absence of this idea explains the unique style of postmodern architecture, which involves mixing elements from different styles rather than focusing on environmental considerations.

 

Regarding the term 'postmodernist,' the 'post' simply indicates a shift from one period to another, like turning a page. It's worth noting that this idea of chronological progression is a modern concept rooted in Christianity, Cartesianism, and Jacobinism. But today, instead of truly breaking away from the past, we seem to just repeat or ignore it rather than moving beyond it.

 

To put it simply, using elements from past architectures in new designs is like how Freud described using memories in dreams. This repetition can be seen in contemporary art trends like 'trans-avantgardism' and neo-expressionism.

 

The second point. Another way 'postmodern' is understood is as a decline in the belief in progress that marked the past two centuries. This belief was rooted in the idea that advancements in arts, technology, knowledge, and freedom would benefit humanity as a whole. While there were debates over who exactly would benefit from progress – whether it be the poor, workers, or the less educated – everyone agreed that progress was essential for human liberation.

After two centuries, we've become more aware of signs suggesting the opposite of progress. Economic and political liberalism, as well as various forms of Marxism, aren't free from suspicion of crimes against humanity during the past two centuries. We can point to specific events, like Auschwitz, to highlight the failure of past ideologies to truly liberate mankind.

 

This realization has left a sense of sadness in our time. We may react with sorrow or even seek utopias, but we struggle to find a positive direction forward.

 

The advancement of technology and science often seems to create more problems than it solves. It's not really progress in the traditional sense anymore. Instead, it seems to happen on its own, without regard for human needs, and often leaves us feeling unstable both mentally and physically. It's like humanity is constantly chasing after new things without fully understanding why or what the purpose is.

 

We're caught up in a world where everything is becoming more complex. Our desire for security, identity, and happiness seems irrelevant compared to the demand to make things more complicated, to remember and synthesize every detail, and to constantly change scale. We're like Gulliver in a world where we never quite fit in. So, the idea of simplicity now seems primitive in comparison.

Now, let's consider the division of humanity into two groups: one dealing with the challenges of complexity and the other focused on basic survival. This division is a significant aspect of the failure of the modern project, which was supposed to benefit all of humanity.

 

Moving on to the third argument, postmodernity also relates to how we express our thoughts in various fields like art, literature, philosophy, and politics. In the art world, there's a sense that the era of avant-gardism is over, and there's a tendency to mock it as outdated. However, I believe it's important to understand that avant-garde movements were actually serious investigations into the assumptions of modernity. To grasp the work of artists like Manet, Duchamp, or Barnett Newman, we should see it as a process similar to psychoanalytic therapy. Just as a patient explores past experiences to understand their current issues, these artists were examining and reworking the ideas of modernity. If we neglect this responsibility, we risk repeating the same problems and conflicts of modernity without making any progress. So, in the context of postmodernity, the term 'post' doesn't mean going back in time but rather analyzing, remembering, and reflecting on the past.

 

 

 

Saturday, 13 April 2024

Terrell Carver's "The Postmodern Marx" (Book Note)

 

 

Terrell Carver's book, "The Postmodern Marx," argues that this apparent chaos has its reasons. He suggests that there have always been multiple interpretations of Marx, each shaped by the reader's chosen texts, philosophical beliefs about language and meaning, and political motivations, whether acknowledged or not.

 

Carver aims to provide an alternative perspective for those interested in Marx's ideas, and he has achieved this goal effectively. Through his collection of essays, written between 1975 and 1998, Carver delves into the complexities of Marx's work and the diverse readings it has inspired. By doing so, he offers valuable insights for newcomers to Marx's thought, helping them navigate through the often convoluted world of Marxist discourse, which frequently invokes Marx without engaging deeply with his actual texts. Overall, Carver's work significantly contributes to the field of Marxist scholarship.

Carver's argument starts with the idea that we can't simply go back to a time before debates and purges within Marxist thought. The notion of a pure, singular "return to Marx" is impossible because we've created multiple interpretations of Marx ourselves. Additionally, Marx's writing is rich and multifaceted, employing various linguistic techniques like irony, satire, parody, reason, and persuasion. Carver aims to understand this complex author by closely examining Marx's language and the language surrounding him.

 

Through this approach, Carver uncovers a Marx that is more intricate and compelling than many might expect based solely on the book's title. He criticizes previous chronologies and editions, opting instead to closely analyze the texts themselves within their social context. This attention to detail makes his interpretation convincing. Several essays in his collection would benefit anyone interested in Marx, particularly sociologists. Often, our exposure to Marx's writings ends after completing our theoretical studies in graduate school, and even if we continue to engage with Marx, it's usually based on our early readings. Marx transcends simple categorizations—he's not merely a founding figure of sociology, a political economist, or a proponent of conflict theory. He was an active revolutionary whose ideas defy orthodox interpretations and resist being pigeonholed into postmodern frameworks.

 

Carver's critique of Derrida's "Spectres of Marx" exemplifies this point well. Carver sees Derrida's interpretation as imaginative but divergent from the actual texts and language of Marx. While Derrida claims to focus on the word, Carver argues that he often loses sight of Marx's actual words. For instance, Derrida's interpretation of the opening of the Manifesto differs significantly from Carver's. Derrida suggests that Marx portrays communism as a specter that will haunt Europe in the future, whereas Carver sees it as a critique of right-wing hysteria, asserting that communism is a fabrication of reactionary forces.

Carver also scrutinizes the conventional views within Marxist circles, focusing on two key relationships: Marx's connection with Hegel and with Engels. His analyses of these relationships challenge commonly held assumptions and force readers to reconsider their fundamental understandings of Marx's intellectual influences.

 

Regarding Marx's relationship with Hegel, Carver doesn't attempt to downplay Hegel's influence on Marx or suggest that Marx merely developed Hegel's ideas. Instead, he argues that Marx engaged with Hegel to address fundamental philosophical questions that existed prior to Hegel. Hegel provided a framework for Marx to explore and critique philosophical concepts from various thinkers. Carver questions why Hegel is emphasized over other philosophers like Aristotle, Democritus, Epicurus, or Shakespeare. He suggests that the notion of a significant Hegel-Marx connection was largely propagated by Engels to make Marx more accessible to his audience, especially as Hegelian political influence waned after 1848. Engels portrayed Marx as the successor to Hegel, which Carver views as a strategic move to elevate Marx's status. However, Carver questions whether Marx truly needed to be associated with any specific philosopher and highlights differences between Marx and Engels regarding Hegel's ideas.

 

Carver's analysis includes examining changes made by Marx and Engels to texts like the German Ideology and their writings about each other. He concludes that contemporary readings of Marx often prioritize Hegel and Engels over Marx himself. This tendency, Carver argues, has led to a distorted view of Marx's original contributions, reducing him to a subordinate figure within a perceived "Holy Family" of Hegel-Engels-Marx, where Marx is overshadowed and misunderstood.

The book delves into various aspects of Marx's writing, including his stylistic precision, use of critique, concepts of political economy, narrative techniques, and political interventions. The concluding chapter explores gender and women in Marx's texts, contributing to the ongoing dialogue between feminism and Marxism.

In a peculiar manner, much of the academic study associated with Marxism resembles a type of fundamentalist biblical scholarship. This involves persistently scrutinizing texts to find elements that support a particular contemporary political viewpoint. Certain texts are emphasized for their significance, while others are disregarded or treated with a sense of discomfort. These less emphasized texts might only be mentioned in bibliographic references, as if to suggest they represent an earlier, less refined version of the thinker in question.

 

Determining what exactly constitutes the core works of Marx has been a longstanding issue. The history of Marxism isn't solely about revolutionary movements; it also involves contentious debates over interpreting Marx's writings, sometimes with grave consequences. Many individuals claim to adhere to Marxism, yet their interpretations of Marx's ideas can vary wildly, leading to the perception that there are as many interpretations of Marx as there are individuals who consider themselves Marxists.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thursday, 25 January 2024

Bryan S. Turner's "Orientalism, Postmodernism and Globalism" (Book Note)

 

With the release of Edward Said's "Orientalism" in 1978, the predominant discourse on global development issues underwent a significant shift. Previously centered on economic considerations and exploitation in the Marxist sense, the focus transitioned to the ideological conditions shaping the production of knowledge. Drawing on literary theory and Foucault's 'archaeology of knowledge,' Said contended that the 'Orient' had been systematically misrepresented by European Orientalists, particularly those from France and England. He analyzed this hegemony as a severe form of mental colonization.

 

The impact of Said's influential, albeit now dated, work cannot be overstated. Over the past decade, there has been an abundance of critical postcolonial literature inspired by Said, Derrida, and Foucault. Like Said, these works scrutinize (mis-)representations and propose alternative perspectives on East-West and North-South relations. In response, there has been a continuous stream of both critical and apologetic statements either defending colonial accounts of 'the Other' or cautioning against the relativism and potential nihilism inherent in Said's perspective on knowledge and history. Some critics argue that anti-Orientalists have themselves succumbed to a form of blatant Occidentalism, presenting simplistic and disparaging accounts of Western scholarship.

 

Bryan S. Turner's recent essay collection breaks away from this pattern. Turner engages with ongoing debates on Orientalism and (post-)modernity in a variety of ways, providing a critical yet not hostile perspective on the postcolonial intellectual landscape. He expresses sympathy for the postcolonial project of deconstructing Orientalism but perceives its anti-essentialist or anti-foundationalist epistemology as an impediment to grasping the 'real Orient.' Within the vaguely deconstructivist ambiance of these discussions, every phenomenon is seen as a discourse, and its connection to reality is deemed tenuous. In the latter part of the book, Turner extends the discussion of epistemological challenges related to representation, interpretation, and reliability to non-Islamic ('Western') societies.

The book is organized into five parts, each addressing different aspects of the Orientalism critique and related issues. In the first part, which centers on religion with a particular focus on Islam, Turner challenges the perspective, advocated by scholars like Ernest Gellner, that beliefs are adopted based on logical consistency. Instead, he argues that people embrace beliefs because they help them navigate the challenges of everyday life. Turner also contests the notion of a lack of civil society in Asian states, asserting that this perception is more connected to the domestic discourse on monarchy and democracy since the 17th century than to Asia itself. This section delves into the Orientalism critique, highlighting its potential pitfalls, such as replacing one hegemonic discourse with another and grappling with the challenges of cultural translation.

 

The second part of the book offers an even-handed assessment of the accomplishments of two prominent Orientalists, Marshall Hodgson and Gustave von Grünenbaum. Turner, in critiquing these scholars, underscores his view that religion is primarily intertwined with everyday practices rather than lofty belief systems. The third part, titled 'Globalism,' explores issues related to globalization and relativism, with a specific focus on revitalistic and politicized Islam. Contrasting individualism with Islamism (or 'Fundamentalism'), Turner provides a nuanced perspective on Islam's fate in the postmodern age. Here, he argues for a sophisticated understanding of Islam, rejecting attempts by both Orientalists and anti-Orientalists to depict the 'true nature of Islam' in simplistic terms. Turner emphasizes the need for nuanced interpretations given the complex reality of Islam's responses to postmodernity, an era when grand narratives are no longer considered credible.

In the fourth part of the book, Turner directs his attention to a direct confrontation with the relationship between postmodernity, enlightenment ideas, and the role of intellectuals. He critiques elitist perspectives on mass culture, highlighting a strong implicit nostalgia in 'critical theory,' particularly in the works of thinkers like Marcuse. Arguing alongside Nietzsche, Turner asserts that "the world should not be bifurcated into a world of superior intellectual values and inferior everyday values." The analysis becomes particularly intriguing when discussing Pierre Bourdieu's "Distinction" and the author's steadfast belief in the existence of hegemonic discourses. Turner, throughout, demonstrates a profound sensitivity to the multiple strategies employed by agents in the contemporary pluralistic, or some would say postmodern, context where overarching symbolic hierarchies are lacking.

 

The subsequent essay on cosmopolitanism and nationalism in sociology serves as a splendid illustration of the problems tackled throughout the volume — issues of generalization, comparison, translation, and ultimately, the challenge of relativism. These concerns are addressed more concretely in the essay on the relationship of English intellectuals to the wider world.

 

The fifth and final part of the book offers enlightening essays on the moral and political predicaments of the contemporary age. Topics include the transition from order to risk (as discussed by Beck), ontological insecurity (Giddens), ambivalence (Bauman), and the reflexive construction of the self. While not entirely persuaded by arguments positing this era as one of radicalized modernity, particularly in terms of periodization, Turner accepts the central tenets of such 'theories of high or late modernity.' He connects these ideas to his analysis of Islam in the conclusion of the book.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Saturday, 9 December 2023

Navigating the Apocalypse Axial Consciousness in a Post Modern Era

 




In an unexpected turn of events, humanity is compelled to confront the "outside" as an "inside," resembling a resurgence of the mythopoeic age, challenging the Promethean aspirations of Modernity—fulfilled despite our best and worst intentions. Modernity was envisioned as a rejection of the mythopoeic mindset, where the boundaries between inner and outer worlds were blurred, and the cosmos formed a complex interwoven tapestry. Scholars dismiss this as poetic fancy or differing worldviews, contrasting it with modern rationality. Yet, what was once dismissed as fantastical dreaming is becoming our actual destiny, albeit in uniquely modern ways.

 

Ironically, we find ourselves questioning, echoing Bruno Latour, whether we were ever truly modern. The founding myth of modernity lies within modernity itself, revealing a profound paradox embedded in the formative moments of the Axial Age mind.

 

The philosophical spirit that animated ancient Greek philosophy, evolving into the "waterless canals" of medieval scholasticism, sought infinite knowledge. Kant challenged this burgeoning hubris, but Hegel's revival of the dream of infinite knowledge brought a strange historical twist. Kant, paradoxically, outlined what this knowledge should be but showed why it couldn't be achieved, simultaneously opening it up as a determinate possibility. Heidegger's insightful discussion elaborates on divine knowledge as intuition, where the difference between infinite and finite intuition lies in creating the object of intuition from the ground up. To originate a thing from scratch implies infinite knowledge, a complete understanding without intermediaries, as the creator and the created form an originative unity. The very notion of "thought" as finite arises only when the creative origin of the thing has no existential connection to the thinker, emphasizing a Cartesian dichotomy.

Hegel envisioned history as the very essence of the human spirit's creativity, a process of remaking the existing world in our image. This transformative journey, a self-positing essence, aimed at achieving infinite or absolute knowledge, reflects the Hegelian perspective. Could it be that Hegel's historical narrative not only speculatively describes but literally unfolds in today's processes? Kant, by revealing the profound contradiction within Modernity's epistemology, exposed the tension between disciplined cognition and the infinite expanses unveiled by experimental evidence. Now, in the final act of Modernity, humankind emerges as an originative force, challenging the boundaries of finite understanding through knowledge of the laws of Nature.

 

Our impact extends beyond geological forces, permeating every scientific domain that has reached a certain originative maturity. In biology, we wield influence as an evolutionary force, shaping the trajectory of life itself. Theoretical physics unveils Promethean potentials, constrained only by our current limitations in harnessing necessary energies for cosmic-scale feats.

 

Examining Descartes, an early modern philosopher, reveals a paradoxical "post-modern" aspect. Descartes takes axial reflexivity to its logical end, subjecting everything to the scrutiny of the critical mind. Faced with Socratic ignorance and the disorientation of discovering flaws in ancient knowledge, Descartes questions if anything can be known with absolute certainty. This extreme reflexivity, where doubt undermines itself, foreshadows the end of modernity and the emergence of the mythopoeic mode of absorptive human consciousness. The struggle with this potential return to a neo-archaic mindset has persisted in European philosophy since Descartes.

 

Philosophy's trajectory since Kant grapples with Hegel's position on these questions. On one extreme, Deleuze views Hegel as deeply problematic, distorting existential movement. Deleuze aligns with Nietzsche in revealing the subterranean dimension of thought, unearthing authentic existential movement. This alternative tradition explores horizontal modes of human consciousness, challenging the myth of abstract rationality that underpins modernity. The complexities and critiques within this historical interplay continue to shape the philosophical discourse.

 

 Deleuze discerned in Nietzsche a rejection of transcendence in favor of immanence, exploring the somatic basis of thought and the depth-dimension of thought as a somatic phenomenon. Nietzsche's writing style, akin to a court jester, a wearer of masks, and a "player" of concepts, reflects his somatic diagnosis of the forces influencing Socrates in "Twilight of the Idols." Nietzsche observed reason becoming tyrannical with Socrates, a response to instinctual forces threatening social structures. This frenzy for the rational, according to Nietzsche, emerged as Athens faced cultural and moral decline, grasping for past glories.

 

In contrast to Deleuze's critical view of Hegel, contemporary philosophers like Zizek see Hegel as an unfinished project, particularly relevant post-Marx and psychoanalysis. Zizek posits that Hegel’s central idea, the Dialectic, is both psychoanalytic and ontological. However, the problem of the "transcendental horizon," escaping the hermeneutic circle of thought and being, persists. Zizek draws key insights from Hegel, despite Deleuze's critique.

 

The first insight revolves around the theory of the "subject" or subjectivity. It suggests that there is no essential core to what we "are"; instead, the "core" is the gap between self and other, constituting subjectivity. Even to oneself, one is an "other," and subject/object are not merely categories of thought but intertwined. Zizek emphasizes the Lacanian notion that "the substance (of self) is already subject before it is substance," revealing a movement within axial consciousness grappling with its archaic-somatic origins.

 

The second insight concerns Hegel’s dialectic, challenging the traditional understanding of neat successions of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis. Hegel’s development of concepts, exemplified in the master-slave relationship, reveals that the second moment is already implicit in the first, and the third moment, the synthesis, recognizes the inextricable unity between the two. Zizek contends that there are no "higher" stages, no vertical progression in the Hegelian dialectic. Instead, it operates as a purely horizontal movement of successive negations, a Moebius logic of concepts. Zizek's insight underscores that subjectivity is the substance of this dialectic, and the substance of reality is already subjective before being recognized as "substance."

Zizek’s second crucial insight into Hegel’s philosophy revolves around Hegel’s profound response to Kant, asserting that the antinomies of reason are not just about the limitations of human knowledge; rather, they are ontological. According to Zizek, Hegel realized that the dialectical ontology of reality precedes and conditions human reason. This means that questions concerning the finitude of the universe, the first cosmological moment, or the existence of a "prime mover" (God) cannot have conclusive answers because reality itself is inherently incomplete and caught in the perpetual act of becoming. Subjectivity shares in this inherent indeterminacy.

 

Hegel’s philosophy, as interpreted by Zizek, offers a language of incompleteness and a framework for thinking about openness and indeterminacy without forcing them into static conceptual categories. Hegel, in this perspective, writes the musical score of reality, finding its grammar and syntax. However, the challenge lies in the recognition that attempting to capture or stabilize this indeterminacy reproduces the ceaseless anxiety and inner tensions of the Axial Mind itself, acknowledging its inherent impossibility. Yet, the comprehensive logic of Hegel remains alluring.

 

In the contemporary context, there is a resistance to the vertical dimension of axial consciousness, evident in Zizek's Heggelian insights and much of his thinking, emphasizing the horizontal over the vertical. This moves beyond the modern vs. postmodern dichotomy, acknowledging that we were never truly modern. The present compels us to confront the resurgence of the mythopoeic past as an ancient and archaic future colliding with the present. Neglecting the category of "infinite knowledge" throughout history, it emerges as the only viable and unexplored category at the end of the Axial Age, encased in centuries of abstraction and idolatry. This revelation, signaling the collapse of dichotomies, may mark the first moment of an apocalypse—a revelation of an unknown future age of consciousness glimpsed dimly through the eyes of fictions, myths, and dream-eyes. To navigate this uncharted territory, there is a call to suspend the scholarly and approach it with the eyes of a new art, crafting a fiction of concepts capable of bringing this future into the past, recognizing that all philosophy comes too late.

 



 

 

 

Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||

  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...