Showing posts with label Guattari. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guattari. Show all posts

Saturday, 4 May 2024

Deleuze & Guattari's "Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia," Chapter 3 The Subject and Enjoyment

 The Process of Recording and Consumption


• The process of recording and consumption is akin to the production of production, with the production of recording itself being produced by the production of production.
• The subject, a subject without a fixed identity, is peripheral to the desiring-machines, defined by the share of the product it takes for itself.
• The subject experiences a reward in the form of a becoming or an avatar, being born of the states it consumes and being reborn with each new state.
• The energy of production is transformed into energy of recording, which is transformed into energy of consummation.
• This residual energy is the motive force behind the third synthesis of the unconscious: the conjunctive synthesis or the production of consumption.
• The opposition between desiring-machines and the body without organs is examined, with the repulsion of these machines giving way to an attraction in the miraculating machine.
• The reconciliation of the two can only occur on the level of a new machine, functioning as "the return of the repressed."
• The term "celibate machine" is used to describe this machine, which succeeds the paranoiac machine and the miraculating machine, forming a new alliance between the desiring-machines and the body without organs.
• The celibate machine reveals the existence of an older paranoiac machine, but it is different from it, manifesting something new and different, a solar force.
• The transformation cannot be explained by the "miraculating" powers the machine possesses due to the inscription hidden inside it.

The Schizoid Experience and the Role of Intensive Quantities

The Autoerotic Experience
• The schizophrenic experience of intensive quantities is a nuptial celebration of a new alliance, birth, and ecstasy.
• These intense quantities are often described as hallucinations and delirium, but they are secondary to the primary emotion, which only experiences intensities, becomings, and transitions.

The Role of Attraction and Repulsion
• The opposition of the forces of attraction and repulsion produces an open series of intensive elements, all of which are positive.
• These intensities are never an expression of the final equilibrium of a system, but consist of an unlimited number of stationary, metastable states through which a subject passes.

The Schizoid's Doctrine
• The schizoid is deeply influenced by the Kantian theory, which fills up matter that has no empty spaces to varying degrees.
• The schizoid's experience is emotionally overwhelming, bringing the schizo as close as possible to matter, to a burning, living center of matter.

The Concept of the Schizo
• The schizo is often conceived as an autistic rag, separated from the real and cut off from life.
• Psychoanalysis reduces a person to a pitiful creature who eternally consumes daddy-and-mommy and nothing else whatsoever.
• The consumption of pure intensities has very little to do with family figures and how very different they are from the conjunctive synthesis of "So that's what it was!" and "So it's me!".

The Concept of the Desiring-Machines in Nietzsche's Philosophy

• The concept of the Desiring-Machines is traced through the points of disjunction on the body without organs, forming circles that converge on the desiring-machines.
• The subject, produced as a residuum alongside the machine, passes through all degrees of the circle and passes from one circle to another.
• The subject is not at the center, which is occupied by the machine, but on the periphery, defined by the states through which it passes.
• The subject is born of each state in the series, continually reborn of the following state that determines him at a given moment.
• Klossowski's commentary on Nietzsche highlights the presence of the Stimmung as a material emotion, constitutive of the most lofty thought and the most acute perception.
• The forces of attraction and repulsion produce a series of intensive states based on the intensity = 0, which designates the body without organs.
• The Nietzschean subject passes through a series of states and identifies these states with the names of history.
• The subject spreads itself along the entire circumference of the circle, the center of which has been abandoned by the ego.
• Nietzsche-as-subject garners euphoric reward from everything that the machine turns out, a product that the reader had thought was no more than the fragmented oeuvre by Nietzsche.
• Nietzsche's vision of the world does not inaugurate a regular succession of landscapes or still lifes, but a parody of the process of recollection of an event.

Deleuze & Guattari's "Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia," Chapter 2. The Body Without Organs (Summary)

 The Conflict Between Desiring-Machines and the Body Without Organs


• The body without organs experiences a conflict with desiring-machines, causing it to resist every coupling of machines and every sound of a machine.
• The body without organs presents its smooth, slippery, opaque, taut surface as a barrier to resist organ-machines.
• The body without organs sets up a counterflow of amorphous, undifferentiated fluid to resist linked, connected, and interrupted flows.
• The body without organs repels desiring-machines, viewing them as an over-all persecution apparatus.
• The genesis of the machine lies in the opposition of the process of production of the desiring-machines and the nonproductive stasis of the body without organs.
• The paranoiac machine is merely an avatar of the desiring-machines, a result of the relationship between the desiring-machines and the body without organs.
• The forms of social production involve an unengendered nonproductive attitude, an element of antiproduction coupled with the process, a full body that functions as a socius.
• The socius as a full body forms a surface over which the forces and agents of production are distributed, appropriating for itself all surplus production and arrogating to itself both the whole and parts of the process.
• Society constructs its own delirium by recording the process of production, but it is not a conscious delirium, but a true consciousness of a false movement.
• Capital is the body without organs of the capitalist, giving to the sterility of money the form where money produces money.
• The machine is responsible for producing a relative surplus value, while embodying itself in the machine as fixed capital.

Capitalism and Production
• Capitalists are aware of the opposition between capital and labor, and use it to extort surplus labor.
• Capital becomes a recording surface that reflects all of production, establishing recording rights.
• The development of relative surplus-value in capitalist mode of production transfers productive powers and social interrelations from labor to capital.
• Capital becomes a mystic being, as all social productive forces seem to be due to capital, not labor itself.

The Body Without Organs and Desiring-Production
• The body without organs serves as a surface for recording the entire process of production of desire.
• Organs are regenerated, "miraculated" on the body of Judge Schreber, who attracts God's rays to himself.
• The enchanted recording surface arrogates all productive forces and organs of production, acting as a quasi cause by communicating the apparent movement (fetish).
• The schizo practices political economy, and all sexuality is a matter of economy.

The Disjunctive Synthesis of Production and the Schizophrenic

The Disjunctive Synthesis of Production
• The law governing the production of recording differs from the production of production.
• The disjunctions of capital are a natural or divine presumposition, affecting the distribution of productive connections from machines to the body without organs.
• The schizophrenic's "either... or... or" refers to the system of possible permutations between differences that always amount to the same.

The Schizophrenic's Body and Disjunctions
• The schizophrenic, possessing the most meager capital, inscribes a world of parries on his body, creating a world of parries.
• The disjunctive synthesis of recording overlaps the connective syntheses of production, extending the process as a method of inscription.

The Divine Nature of Disjunctions
• The divine is inseparable from the disjunctions he uses to divide himself into parts: earlier empires, later empires, and later empires of a superior God, and those of an inferior God.

The Role of Disjunctive Syneses in Paranoia
• Freud emphasizes the importance of disjunctive syntheses in Schreber's delirium and delirium as a general phenomenon.
• The recording of desire goes through various stages in the formation of the Oedipus complex, but the genealogy of desire assumes disjunctions.
• The schizo is constantly subjected to interrogation and cross-examination, formulated in terms of the existing social code.

Psychoanalysis and the Oedipal Triangle

• Psychoanalysis often uses the Oedipal triangle as its basis for understanding psychotic phenomena.
• The schizophrenic often manipulates the Oedipal triangle, introducing his own reference points and breaking through the simplistic terms and functions of the Oedipal triangle.
• The full body is introduced as a third term in the series of divine forms, rejecting attempts to impose triangulation implying it was produced by parents.
• The schizophrenic's system of coordinates is based on his own recording code, which does not coincide with the social code or coincides with it to parody it.
• The schizophrenic scrambles all the codes, shifting from one code to another according to the questions asked.
• The recording process affects the drawings themselves, showing up in the form of lines standing for "catastrophe" or "collapse" that are so many disjunctions surrounded by spirals.
• Despite the attachment of organ-machines to the body without organs, the body remains fluid and slippery.
• Agents of production alight on the body and cling to it, such as sunbeams containing thousands of tiny spermatozoids.
• All this happens and is all recorded on the surface of the body without organs, including the copulations of the agents, divisions of God, and the genealogys marking it off into squares like a grid.

Deleuze & Guattari's "Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia," Chapter 1. The Desiring-Machines (Summary)

 The Machine in Everyday Life

• Everyday life is a machine, functioning smoothly and intermittently.
• Organs, energy sources, and other machines are interconnected, producing a flow that is interrupted by each other.
• The human body is a machine, with functions such as breathing, eating, talking, and breathing.
• Judge Schreber's solar anus is a model of a machine, capable of producing and explaining the process theoretically.
• A schizophrenic's walk outdoors is a better model than a neurotic lying on an analyst's couch.
• Everything is a machine, from celestial machines to alpine machines, all connected to the body.
• Lenz's walk is a reflection of this machine-like existence, contrasting with his relationship with his pastor and his relationship with nature.
• The self and non-self, both inside and outside, no longer hold any meaning.

The Desiring Machines in Samuel Beckett's Works

• The characters' self-locomotion and gaits in Beckett's works are compared to a finely tuned machine.
• The bicycle-horn machine in Beckett's works is compared to the mother-anus machine.
• The Oedipus complex in Beckett's works is examined, focusing on the repression of desiring-machines.
• The machine's function and function are also explored, such as the production of sexual pleasure.
• The schizophrenic's experiences are not merely aspects of nature but a process of production.
• The relationship between nature and industry is examined, with industry being the opposite of nature, extracting raw materials from nature, and returning refuse to nature.
• The concept of production, distribution, and consumption is discussed, implying that there are no relatively independent spheres or circuits.
• The real truth lies in delirium, where there is no such thing as relatively independent spheres or circuits.
• Everything is production, including production of productions, actions, passions, recording processes, distributions, and consumptions.
• The recording processes are immediately consumed, consumed, and reproduced, making them the productions of one and the same process.

Understanding the Concept of Man and Nature

The Human Essence and Nature
• The human essence of nature and man's essence become one within nature through production or industry.
• Industry is seen as a fundamental identity with nature as production of man and by man.

The Role of Man in Nature
• Man is in intimate contact with all forms of life, responsible for even the stars and animal life.
• He is the eternal custodian of the machines of the universe.

The Process of Production
• Man and nature are not bipolar opposites but are one essential reality, the producer-product.
• Production as process overtakes all idealistic categories and constitutes a cycle whose relationship to desire is that of an immanent principle.

The Concept of Schizophrenia
• Schizophrenia is the universe of productive and reproductive desiring-machines, universal primary production as "the essential reality of man and nature."
• Desiring-machines are binary machines, obeying a binary law or set of rules governing associations.
• Desire constantly couples continuous flows and partial objects that are by nature fragmentary and fragmented.

The Concept of Desiring-Machines and Production

• Desiring-machines are partial objects that produce other flows, interrupted by other partial objects.
• Each organ-machine interprets the world from its own flux, interpreting everything in terms of seeing.
• The coupling within the partial object-flow connective synthesis also has another form: product/producing.
• Producing is always something "grafted onto" the product, and desiring-production is production of production.
• The Cahiers de I'art brut deny the existence of a specific, identifiable schizophrenic entity.
• A schizophrenic table is described as a process of production which is that of desire.
• The pure "thisness" of the object produced is carried over into a new act of producing.
• The surface of the table is eaten up by the supporting framework, a necessary consequence of its mode of production.
• The rule of continually producing production, of grafting producing onto the product, is a characteristic of desiring-machines or of primary production: the production of production.
• The satisfaction the handyman experiences when he plugs something into an electric socket or diverts a stream of water cannot be explained in terms of "playing mommy and daddy," or by the pleasure of violating a taboo.

The Concept of Producing and the Identity of a Product

• The identity of producing and the product is a third term in the linear series, creating an enormous, undifferentiated object.
• The 'bricoleur' is adept at performing diverse tasks but does not subordinate each task to the availability of raw materials and tools.
• The rules of the 'bricoleur' are to make do with 'whatever is at hand,' a set of tools and materials that are finite and heterogeneous.
• The machines run so badly that their component pieces fall apart, allowing them to return to nothingness.
• The full body without organs is the unproductive, sterile, unengendered, and unconsumable.
• Desire desires death and life, as the organs of life are the working machine.
• The body without organs is nonproductive but is produced at a certain place and time in the connective synthesis.
• The imageless, organless body, the nonproductive, exists right where it is produced, in the third stage of the binary-linear series.
• The full body without organs belongs to the realm of antiproduction, which is a characteristic of the connective or productive synthesis.

Wednesday, 3 April 2024

Deleuze's "Assemblage"

 

In Deleuze and Guattari's work, the concept of "assemblage" deals with the interplay between structure and change, organization and contingency. The term "assemblage" translates from the French word "agencement," which refers to the process of arranging or fitting together rather than a static arrangement. An assemblage is not merely a predetermined set of parts assembled into a predefined structure, nor is it a random collection of things. Instead, it is a dynamic whole that expresses some identity and claims a territory.

 

To understand the concept of assemblage, we can look at how it's used in various fields. In geology, for example, it refers to a group of fossils that characterize a particular stratum, showing a contingent arrangement of elements expressing a specific character. Similarly, in archaeology and ecology, an assemblage represents a collection of heterogeneous elements sharing a common habitat.

 

An assemblage includes diverse elements brought together in specific relations, expressing qualities, affects, and effectivity. Deleuze and Guattari emphasize that we don't fully understand an assemblage until we see what it can do, how it functions. Assemblages select elements from their surroundings and organize them in a particular way, converging naturally and artificially to form a veritable invention.

 

For example, Deleuze and Guattari describe a scene from Freud's work involving a child observing a horse pulling an omnibus. This scene is considered an assemblage, comprising the horse, the omnibus, and the street, as well as various active and passive affects circulating within the context of the individuated assemblage. These affects, such as being whipped or falling, demonstrate what the horse "can do" within the assemblage.

In Deleuze and Guattari's framework, "assemblages" are dynamic formations that create territories rather than just occupying space. Territories, like homes or personal identities, express a claim and stake in a particular space or arrangement of elements. They are continuously made and unmade, undergoing processes of territorialization and deterritorialization.

 

Consider the example of "home" as an assemblage. Home is not simply a physical space but a continual attempt to create comfort and familiarity through the arrangement of objects, practices, and feelings. Even transient spaces like an airline seat or a stroll in the neighborhood can become a form of home through personalization and comfort-seeking behaviors.

 

Similarly, personal identities can be understood as assemblages composed of various traits and qualities that express a particular form of identity. These traits, such as clothing or demeanor, constitute an identity-assemblage that can be recognized and understood by others, even if specific elements are absent or different.

 

Assemblages are less about fixed objects and qualities and more about lines and speeds, including patterns of behavior, habits, and rhythms. They also encompass systems of signs and meanings, known as collective assemblages of enunciation, which include discourses, words, and non-corporeal relations.

 

2

Entering into an assemblage involves adopting its particular relations of speed, effectivity, and language, rather than merely imitating its outward appearance. This process of becoming allows individuals to embody the qualities and affects associated with a particular assemblage.

 

In this section, I aim to explore how the concept of assemblage can offer new insights into the relationship between humans and technology, a key topic in technology studies. Traditional approaches to this relationship tend to oversimplify the complexity involved. By examining three common perspectives (the received view, the contextual view, and the view of articulation) using the example of the mobile telephone, I will demonstrate how the concept of assemblage can provide a more nuanced understanding.

 

The first perspective, known as "the received view of culture and technology," sees humans and technology as distinct entities that interact with each other. According to this view, technologies are considered external tools separate from humans. Debates often arise regarding whether technologies control humans (technological determinism) or vice versa (social determinism). When studying technologies like mobile phones from this perspective, researchers focus on the development of the technology itself and its impact on society, viewing mobile phones as discrete objects with their own identities.

 

The second perspective suggests that we should examine technologies within their social contexts. Technologies are seen as embedded in society, shaping and being shaped by human interactions. Researchers like Philip Howard argue for an embedded media perspective, emphasizing how communication tools are integrated into daily life. This approach acknowledges the interplay between human agency and technological affordances but still maintains a separation between humans and technologies.

 

For example, studying the use of mobile phones among teenagers involves understanding how they utilize various features for communication, social interaction, and entertainment. While this perspective highlights the integration of technology into everyday life, it still treats the mobile phone as a distinct entity introduced into the social context.

 

Third  perspective on the relationship between humans and technology is the concept of articulation. Articulation refers to the connection or disconnection of different elements to form identities or unities. For example, think of an articulated lorry, where different cabs can be connected to different trailers, resulting in different trucks each time. Jennifer Slack suggests that context, which is often seen as a theoretical problem, should be viewed as constitutive of technology and vice versa. In this model of articulation, the context shapes the technology and is shaped by it, and technologies cannot be separated from their context.

 

Articulations are historically contingent and require power to make, sustain, transform, and break connections between elements. This applies to both technology and human identities. Looking at the study of mobile phones from an articulation perspective raises questions about how mobile phone technology has been connected to various functions, discourses, populations, ideologies, and policies. Unlike the previous perspectives, articulation emphasizes the contingent connections between elements.

 

3

Comparing articulation to assemblage, we find similarities and differences. Assemblages involve heterogeneous parts forming provisional wholes, including qualities, affects, and flows of agency. While articulation focuses on contingent connections, assemblage also considers territorialization and expression. For instance, considering the example of mobile phones, an assemblage perspective would examine the combination of thumb-key software and transmission, highlighting how the hand becomes the phone and vice versa. This perspective also considers the cultural aspects, such as how mobile phones are referred to in different contexts and their impact on behavior and space. Assemblages are dynamic arrangements of elements with their own patterns of movement and rest, constantly dispersing and reassembling in different configurations.

The concept of assemblage extends beyond individual instances to encompass broader, interconnected systems that operate across various sites and scales. Deleuze and Guattari emphasize that assemblages can form vast constellations, shaping cultures or entire eras. For instance, they cite Foucault's analysis of disciplinary mechanisms in prisons, highlighting how such systems are intertwined with other societal structures like education, workplaces, and hospitals.

 

Returning to the example of mobile phones, focusing solely on individual or group usage overlooks how these specific assemblages reflect broader functions or principles. Deleuze and Guattari describe these overarching principles as abstract machines. In the case of mobile phones, there's a concept akin to "mobile privatization," emphasizing mobility, autonomy, and individual empowerment within neoliberal contexts. This abstract machine informs various assemblages, including self-service systems and others.

 

Each assemblage is entered into locally, involving bodily actions, linguistic expressions, and collective enunciations. By engaging with these assemblages, individuals enact and are influenced by the abstract machine associated with them. Assemblages demonstrate how institutions, organizations, practices, and habits intersect and transform, creating and dismantling territories while opening or closing lines of flight.

 

Deleuze envisions a shift towards control societies characterized by continuous monitoring and communication, rather than physical confinement. He emphasizes the need to analyze collective apparatuses beyond individual machines, focusing on the assemblages we participate in and create. Resistance to control-assemblages requires vigilance at every moment, as new configurations of desire, machines, and statements emerge and challenge existing structures.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||

  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...