Roland Barthes'
semiotic animal explores the nexus between humans and animals, highlighting the
role of animals in shaping cultural metaphors, myths, and identity. The cat, as
a biotope, assimilates with various drives that reinforce the isotope of experiences.
The cat's tendency for comfort is a radical perception of fantasy that delivers
essential schemas of transcendence. By stressing on the desire for comfort in
the cat, Barthes gives expression to his own desire for comfort, which he seeks
in his mother.
Barthes presents the cat as an animal animated phantasmatic object that stands
for the homey idea of "corner" that normally occurs between mother
and child. The cat's relation with the space in the verb "to sleep"
is an expression of "the pronominal I" that mirrors the self as
sleeping. An interesting parallelism may also be drawn in the movement of
animal and non-human animal, as Barthes walks towards a platform that is
cat-like during a lecture at the College de France.
The structural difference with fixed nouns supplies the discursive prosopopeia
(the figure of personification which is absent) where cat as a fictional
character shows the ethological concerns analogous to cognitive and behavioral
understanding. The function of the existential fantasy of self with the other
(cat) as stereotyping becomes the foreclosure of truth. The difference of self
and cat posits the uncanny hypothesis where cat acts as a pre-established
machine for the repressive mechanism in self.
The Barthesian cat is anti-Cartesian in the sense that it covers a dual space
both of the self and the other. This dual space generates a semantic ambiguity
between "the correspondence" and "relation," i.e.,
cat/self. The cat looking for "stereotyping of the localization"
suggests that it is an illusion of the sovereign good that can be idealized for
that space. The indispensable schema for narrating the self through the
expression of the cat, which is Heimlich (domestic, intimate, secret), becomes
the subject that remains at the side of the mirror.
Cat represents Barthes's inner psychic space, playing between the real and the
unreal. To Barthes, cat is the "objective co-relative" that
correlates the self with the anonymous cat. The active semiology becomes the
medium of conscious fantasies and serves as the hyper-individual level where
Barthes speaks about the basic fantasy that is part of the personal history,
aimed at the discursive line of flight. The transference of the self via the
detour of writing becomes a mediating point for the symbolic reading of the
text.
Lacan (1999) states that for objectification in psychological matters it is
subject, at its very core, to a law of misrecognition that governs the subject
not only as observed but also as observer.
Roland Barthes's metaphor of the dog as an extension of the self is a
reflection on the wounds of Narcissism. The animal subject and wounds of
Narcissism are seen as an extra-textual space that allows for a phantasmic
reading of the self as the text. Barthes posits a binary between plant and
animal to relate the space between utopia and heterotopia. The image of animal
as narcissistic expression pierces the shafts of cognition and dissolution of
the visualized disconnection from the real object. The subjective expression of
the veiled self-identity is attained through active self-consciousness, where
the difference of "self" is held by unraveling the truth that other
animals bring to oneself.
Plant as a contingency of experience displays all focus of attention on its
detail, while its meaninglessness strives for zero degree meaning. Barthes
observes plant as a text that is also compared with animals, as they are
conspicuous spectacles of pure effect. This comparison fills the lack of
obtaining the desired object, as Barthes seeks to fill the empty space within
himself with arbitrary linguistic sign.
Dog becomes a relevant trope to express the self, as it becomes the wound that
flags the self via the functions of analogy of dog as "satori" of
meaning. The magical presence of dog as a referent expresses the inexpressible
being-there of the referent, which can only truly appear as "reality
effect." The linguistic expression of dog is a central supplement to the
"fundamental absence," as Barthes begins to remember the features of
"dog" when it is absent.
Barthes's selection of the particular trope suggests that it is a continuation
of a specific fantasy, which is also a reversal to the fantasy of the cat. Dogs
are fascinating because they are like men without reason (and without madness).
The discussion of dog with the "being saturated with man" suggests
the annachronistic link with the self through the rhetorical trope.
Roland Barthes's work explores the concept of the animal as an object of affect
for humans, arguing that it is the place one occupies rather than their psyche
that is the subject of affect. The paradoxical fitting of the dog by Barthes is
an expression of re-presenting the real, the fetish, and a lack where the
perversion of self denies tearing the referent by reading one's own body. By
representing the dog as a host of "real presence," Barthes attempts
to extrapolate the provocation of other and memory that leads to the
transformation of self.
The linguistic autonomy of accounting the dog as "our animal"
represents the symbolic order of the real. Barthes's personal
"biographemes" articulate the problem of existence between three
registers introduced by Jacques Lacan: the Real, the Imaginary, and the
Symbolic. The expression of dog and cat becomes both the condensation and
displacement, acting as a "psychotic experience" of reality. Thus,
the imaginary relationship between the dog and the self is established through
psychotic experience that builds up mediation between the self and the idea.
Barthes's digression toward distinction of "the animal from the
beast" associates him with the metonymic signifier, where the beast-like
signifier is a metaphor to men. This constitution of the personal code causes
symptomatic storehouses of mutilated images. Barthes considers animals to be
"having a soul" that posits affect on humans, and every symptom and
every oniric symbol is a compromise.
Barthes offers the supplementary crack for reading the obssessional production
of "diffuse affective" that is hysteric in nature. The hysteric
self-identity isrendered with the "shimmering," which is a specific
and rare affective mode. Dog as a site of desire is condemned as a denomination
of the realized animal in the self, confirming the singularity of the being.
The recurrent trope of "Dog" in Barthes is a metonymic signifier of
self suggesting the two-fold of a Dasein. By drawing parallelism between
"haiku" and "dog," Barthes attempts to sense the
co-relation between the self and the environment. Through the 'dog' metaphor,
Barthes believes that aesthetic judgment has a liberatory critical power that
complements the more deterministic type of thought found in cognition and
morality.
Saturday, 25 May 2024
Semiotic Animal (Roland Barthes)
Thursday, 25 April 2024
Roland Barthes' "Dominici, or the Triumph of Literature" (Summary)
"Dominici, or the Triumph of Literature" is an
interesting work because it foreshadows later ideas from Barthes, particularly
in his 1977 work. Here, Barthes shows that "literature" isn't
something separate from everyday life and its power dynamics. Instead, he examines
a case where a rural laborer, Dominici, is judged using language deeply rooted
in literature: the judges describe his motives using literary clichés. They
also feel superior because they speak in a more polished, literary style than
Dominici. Even journalists reporting on the trial turn it into a literary
narrative, reinforcing existing literary conventions.
Although the essay doesn't use the term explicitly, it's a
classic example of how dominant ideas are reinforced through interactions
between different institutions and forms of discourse – in this case,
literature, the law, and journalism – all shaping the narrative about those who
have little voice in response. Later, Barthes reflected on this approach in his
columns, where he theorized about how discourse (or "mythology")
circulates in society, making certain views of the world seem natural and
universal. This leaves little room for alternative perspectives, which are
often dismissed as "unnatural," "perverse," "exotic,"
or "abnormal."
The Dominici trial was based on a particular view of
psychology, which happened to align with the literature favored by the
bourgeois establishment. Since there wasn't clear physical evidence, they
relied on understanding the accused's mental state, often reflecting the
mindset of the judges and prosecutors. However, these mentalities, such as that
of the rural laborer Dominici and the judicial system, likely didn't work the
same way. Yet, Dominici was judged based on a supposed "universal"
psychology derived from bourgeois novels and essentialist psychology, leading
to his condemnation.
This trial illustrates how official institutions, like the
judicial system and literary circles, use language to assert authority over
those accused. The belief in the transparency and universality of language
allows judges to communicate with defendants, despite the significant
differences in their backgrounds and understanding. However, this so-called
universal language actually serves to reinforce the psychology of those in power,
reducing individuals to simplistic labels and disregarding their actual actions
or consciousness. This psychology, rooted in utilitarianism and lacking
consideration for individual experiences, still claims to understand and judge
based on an assumed inner "soul" or conscience.
The psychology used in Dominici's trial comes from
traditional literature, particularly the kind that focuses on depicting human
life realistically. It's this idea of the "human document" that led
to Dominici's condemnation. In a surprising twist, Justice and literature have
joined forces, sharing their methods and revealing their close connection.
Writers like Giono and Salacrou sit alongside judges, blurring the lines
between law and literature.
Even the prosecution gets in on the literary action, with
the Public Prosecutor being described as an exceptional storyteller with wit
and charm. Even the police get poetic, describing Dominici in elaborate terms
like a master of disguise playing with people's emotions. The courtroom is filled
with rhetoric, metaphors, and dramatic language straight out of classical
literature, accusing the old shepherd.
Justice adopts the mask of realistic literature, while
literature itself eagerly collects new "human" stories from the
courtroom. Ironically, it's literature that originally imposed certain
psychological labels on the accused, now seeking to find those labels reflected
in their faces.
In contrast to the literature that saturates us with
supposed realism and humanity, there exists a literature that evokes deep
emotion. The Dominici trial embodies this type of literature as well. It wasn't
just about writers craving reality or eloquent storytellers capturing
attention; regardless of the accused's guilt, there was also the chilling
spectacle of a terror that threatens us all. It's the fear of being judged by a
power that only wants to hear its own language spoken. We all face the
potential of becoming like Dominici, not as murderers, but as accused
individuals stripped of our own language or forced to adopt that of our
accusers, leading to humiliation and condemnation. To deprive someone of their
language in the name of language itself is the initial step in all legal
atrocities.
Wednesday, 21 February 2024
Roland Barthes' "The Structuralist Activity" (Summary)
Structuralism isn't exactly a formal group or movement,
at least not yet, because most authors labeled as structuralists aren't
consciously following a shared doctrine. It's also not just a set of words or
vocabulary. The term "structure" is widely used across social
sciences, making it hard to distinguish who is truly a structuralist. Words
like functions, forms, signs, and significations are also commonly used and
don't necessarily mark someone as a structuralist.
To understand structuralism, we need to look at certain
pairs of ideas like "signifier/signified" and
"synchronic/diachronic." These pairs are important because they
relate to language and time, which are central in structuralist thinking. The
first pair comes from linguistics, especially Saussure's work, which focuses on
the relationship between words and their meanings. The second pair deals with
how we view history. "Synchronic" refers to looking at a specific
moment in time, while "diachronic" looks at historical processes over
time.
Interestingly, the main opposition to structuralism often
comes from Marxists, who disagree with its implications for historical analysis
rather than its structural concepts.
So, in academic terms, structuralism is a theoretical
framework that examines the underlying structures and systems that shape
language, society, and history. It involves analyzing the relationships between
elements, like signifiers and signifieds in language, and synchronic and
diachronic perspectives in history.
Structuralism isn't just about philosophers; it can apply
to various artists too. It's not a fixed school of thought but more like a way
of experiencing and understanding structure. Whether you're analyzing or
creating, structuralism is about mentally engaging with structure.
So, what exactly is this structuralist activity? It's a
series of mental operations aimed at revealing how things function. The goal is
to reconstruct an object in a way that shows its inner workings or
"functions." It's like creating a model that helps us see what wasn't
obvious before.
This process involves breaking down the real world,
studying its parts, and then putting them back together in a new way. Some
might think this sounds trivial, but it's actually quite profound. By doing
this, we reveal new insights and make things more understandable. It's like
adding a layer of intellect to the object.
This intellectual addition is crucial because it helps us
understand not just the object itself, but also its significance in human
history and society. It's about understanding our place in the world and how we
interact with it. So, while structuralism might seem like just rearranging
things, it's actually about gaining deeper understanding and insight into
ourselves and the world around us
Structuralism isn't just about observing the world; it's
about actively reshaping it into something understandable. It's like creating a
mirror image of reality, not to duplicate it, but to make sense of it. So, you
could say structuralism is essentially about imitation.
In this sense, there's no real difference between
structuralism as an intellectual pursuit and artistic endeavors. Both involve
mimicking reality, not by copying its substances, but by understanding its
functions. Whether it's analyzing language, society, or art, or creating
something new, like music or literature, the process is similar.
For example, when linguists break down speech sounds into
patterns, or when scholars dissect myths to understand their function, they're
doing the same thing as artists who compose music or write literature. They're
all revealing the inner workings of their subjects through structured representations.
It doesn't matter if the starting point is something
already organized, like a language or society, or something scattered, like
ideas waiting to be formed. What defines art or analysis isn't the nature of
the original object, but the way it's reconstructed and enhanced by human
technique.
2
So, structuralism isn't just about the end result; it's
about the method used to achieve it. By reconstructing objects to reveal their
functions, structuralism creates a distinct approach to understanding and
creating. That's why we talk about structuralist activity rather than just the
outcomes of that activity.
The structuralist activity involves two key operations:
dissection and articulation. Dissection entails breaking down the initial
object into movable fragments whose arrangement creates meaning. These
fragments, like squares in Mondrian's art, musical series by Pousseur, or
elements in Butor's Mobile, have significance only in relation to their
boundaries. These boundaries distinguish them from other fragments and link
them to a paradigm—a set of related objects or units.
Understanding the paradigm is crucial in structuralism.
Objects within a paradigm must share some similarities and differences for
their meanings to be distinct. For instance, in French, the words
"poisson" and "poison" differ in meaning due to shared
characteristics like dental sounds but distinct features like sonority.
Similarly, Mondrian's squares share shapes but differ in proportions and
colors.
The dissection operation creates a scattered array of
fragments, but these fragments aren't chaotic. Each belongs to a virtual group
or reservoir, forming an organized system governed by the principle of minimal
difference. This principle ensures that each fragment relates intelligently to
others within its group, setting the stage for the next operation:
articulation.
After identifying the units, structural thinkers must
establish rules for their association, a process called articulation. In every
structural endeavor, whether in arts or discourse, there's a commitment to
regularity rather than strict formalism. The recurrence of units and their
associations gives the work structure and meaning, combating the randomness of
chance.
These rules of combination, called forms in linguistics,
ensure that the arrangement of units isn't merely haphazard. They give
coherence to the work, transforming it from a random assembly into something
meaningful. This is why abstract works, despite lacking figurative elements,
can still be considered art—they demonstrate the human capacity to impose order
on chaos.
3
The constructed simulacrum doesn't merely mirror the
world; it introduces a new category of objects: the functional. This aligns
with developments in information theory and research. More importantly, it
underscores how humans imbue things with meaning. Structuralism, in essence,
focuses on the process of meaning-making rather than the meanings themselves.
This perspective isn't entirely new; humanity has always
sought to understand the world. What's novel is the emphasis on how meaning is
generated and at what cost. The goal isn't just to assign meanings but to
comprehend the process of meaning fabrication. Thus, the object of
structuralism isn't merely man with meanings but rather man as the creator of
meanings—a Homo significans engaged in the continual production of semantic
significance.
According to Hegel, the ancient Greeks found awe in
nature, listening to its mysteries and attributing divine significance, like
the god Pan, to natural phenomena. Today, in our socialized world where even
nature is imbued with human influence, structural thinkers, much like the
ancient Greeks, seek meaning within culture. They perceive culture not as a
collection of stable truths but as a vast human endeavor constantly creating
meaning.
For structuralists, the act of meaning-making is more
crucial than the meanings themselves. Structuralism sees creation and analysis
as inseparable; they are ongoing processes rather than static objects. Like
ancient prophets who sensed meaning without necessarily naming it,
structuralists engage with meaning without being limited by explicit
definitions.
Literature, especially, embodies this prophetic nature,
both speaking to and questioning the world, reshaping meanings as it interacts
with reality. Despite accusations of being detached from reality, structuralism
doesn't ignore history. Instead, it seeks to connect historical content and
forms, bridging material and intellectual, ideological, and aesthetic aspects.
Structuralists understand that their approach is just one
form of understanding the world, subject to change like everything else. They
find validation not in permanence but in their ability to reinterpret old
languages and adapt to new ones. As history evolves, so will structuralism,
always ready to embrace the emergence of new languages that speak to the human
condition in fresh ways.
Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...
-
The concept of "collective memory" encompasses a broad range of phenomena, including rituals, traditions, myths, historical events...
-
, first published in 1844 under the pseudonym Vigilius Haufniensis, is a profound exploration of the human condition, addressing the natur...
-
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...