The emergence of memory sciences in nineteenth-century
Europe was intricately tied to processes of secularization and the development
of a scientific approach to understanding the human mind. Particularly in the
latter part of the century, spanning from 1874 to 1886 according to Hacking's
delineation, there was a growing belief that human memory and recollection held
the key to understanding mental life. It was increasingly asserted that many
life issues could only be comprehended and resolved through precise
reconstructions of individuals' life stories or the collective histories of
groups.
As this cultural shift unfolded, the traditional practice
of the art of memory began to wane, replaced by a scientific or
science-oriented approach that focused on systematically studying the
structures, processes, and functions of memory, as well as other aspects of
human physiology, psychology, and daily social interactions. The burgeoning field
of memory sciences, with psychology and psychoanalysis playing significant
roles, heralded an era of intense scrutiny and exploration into the workings of
memory and recollection. This scientific inquiry into memory was closely
intertwined with broader efforts to understand and narrativize the human
psyche.
The narrative turn in social and cultural sciences, which
gained momentum in the latter part of the twentieth century, shed light on the
fundamental role of narrative and storytelling in shaping and articulating the
human psyche. This interdisciplinary focus underscored the centrality of
narrative forms in comprehending various aspects of psychology, including
perception, cognition, motivation, emotion, and social dynamics. Numerous
empirical studies have highlighted the narrative structuring of memory
processes and recollection achievements, emphasizing how memories often take
the form of stories or are integral components of larger narrative frameworks.
In the nineteenth century, the engagement with the past
and history drove a scientific research agenda that aimed not only for
knowledge and enlightenment but also for enriching life and enhancing
performance. Memory research, particularly in psychology, became intertwined
with a broader memory politics and ethics of recollection, wherein
reconstructing the past became a central activity for reason-oriented life
management. Remembering and recollecting truthfully and comprehensively were
considered psychological dispositions essential for controlling and
disciplining various aspects of daily life, promising psychosocial benefits.
This cultural ethos emphasized authenticity and veracity
in narrating one's own history, reflecting a commitment to psychological
realism. The narrative structuring of recollection played a crucial role in
shaping personal identity and self-perception, with the past informing present
actions and future aspirations. In psychiatry, psychoanalysis, and
psychotherapy, the meticulous exploration and emotional processing of one's
past were seen as pathways to overcoming negative patterns of thought and
behavior, thereby enabling personal growth and fulfillment. Freudian concepts
like transference and psychic causality underscored the dynamic and creative
nature of recollection, wherein memories constantly evolve and acquire new
meanings in light of new experiences and developmental stages.
Memories are not static entities but rather undergo
constant change, often through their integration into an evolving life
narrative. Personal memories are not fixed "objects" but rather
complex constructions that are continuously shaped and reshaped during the
process of recollection. This perspective is fundamental to narrative cognitive
psychology, which views memories, even the most intimate ones, as influenced by
cultural and social semantics, as well as by linguistic and other symbolic
repertoires and modes of expression. Additionally, personal memories frequently
result from dialogues and other collaborative processes of co-construction.
These concepts have long been applied in narrative
psychotherapy, which has evolved from earlier practices such as psychoanalysis.
While early psychoanalysis focused on the therapeutic power of talking cures
and the reconstruction of autobiographical self-stories, modern narrative
psychotherapy encompasses a diverse array of narrative-based therapeutic
techniques. Despite their differences, these approaches share a common belief
in the therapeutic value of narrative in reshaping one's self-perception and relationships.
Transformations in self-narratives have been shown to correlate with
significant psychological changes, particularly in the context of trauma
recovery.
Despite some objections, the cultural emphasis on memory
and recollection has persisted. Nietzsche, for instance, criticized certain
historical approaches for their potential to stifle individual and collective
agency by fixating on the past. Nevertheless, the prevailing view has been that
a thorough understanding of the past, achieved through scientific methods, is
essential for shaping present identities and future aspirations. This
perspective emphasizes the interconnectedness of past, present, and future in
shaping individual and collective identities.
2
Both narrative psychology and psychotherapy play crucial
roles in deciphering the "dark traces of the past" and constructing
coherent narratives of personal and collective experience. However, they are
not without criticism, particularly regarding the pressure to construct complete
life narratives, which may be unrealistic and potentially detrimental to
well-being.
The narrative character of memory construction highlights
the communicative and discursive nature of the past, present, and future.
Representations of events and experiences are not mere reproductions but rather
active constructions shaped by cognitive, emotional, and motivational
processes. Language and other symbolic media play crucial roles in shaping and
transmitting these representations, making memory and recollection inherently
cultural phenomena.
Bartlett's groundbreaking research in cognitive
psychology challenged the prevailing views established by Ebbinghaus's approach
to memory, which dominated much of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
While Ebbinghaus sought to formulate a general theory of memory based on
supposedly neutral experiments with nonsense syllables, Bartlett took a
different approach. He emphasized the active, constructive nature of memory and
recollection, asserting that cultural context and cognitive frameworks
profoundly influence how memories are formed and recalled.
In Bartlett's view, individuals do not passively memorize
objective events but rather transform them into meaningful experiences that
align with their existing knowledge and cultural schemas. Memory is not a
static storage medium but a dynamic process of construction and reconstruction,
shaped by cultural influences and cognitive mechanisms. Bartlett's research
revealed that memory operates both actively and creatively, with recollections
being meaningfully structured compositions rather than neutral reproductions of
past events.
Bartlett introduced the concept of "schemata"
or organized units of knowledge, which play a crucial role in shaping memory
and recollection. He demonstrated this through experiments where participants
recalled unfamiliar stories by assimilating them into familiar cultural
frameworks. This process highlighted the active role of memory in creating
coherent narratives from fragmented experiences, emphasizing the narrative
structuring of events.
These insights revolutionized cognitive psychology,
leading to a shift away from the idea of memory as a passive repository of
information towards understanding it as an active, culturally embedded process.
Modern theories of memory recognize its dynamic and constructive nature, with
each act of recollection being influenced by present cultural contexts and
future expectations.
Furthermore, Bartlett's work laid the foundation for
understanding complex psychological phenomena, such as dissociative identity
disorder, within a narrative framework. By emphasizing the importance of
autobiographical narratives and the role of trauma in shaping identity,
Bartlett's approach contributed to a deeper understanding of the human psyche and
its connection to memory.
The complex case of multiple personality remains a
prominent example of how memory and recollection shape an individual's
psychological life. Often, buried memories of traumatic experiences,
inaccessible to the conscious mind, can cause significant distress and hinder
one's ability to function. Early therapeutic efforts emphasized the importance
of remembering and talking about these experiences as a crucial step toward
healing.
However, therapists must navigate the risk of inadvertently
eliciting false memories. The phenomenon of "false memory syndrome"
has led to public skepticism and even legal disputes over the authenticity of
recovered memories, particularly in cases of alleged sexual abuse. The cultural
climate surrounding discussions of sexual abuse has influenced individuals to
construct narratives of victimhood, sometimes attributing traumatic experiences
to individuals who are later found to be innocent.
The process of memory work in psychotherapy involves
embedding recovered memories into an autobiographical narrative, often
following a standardized structure. This highlights the cultural encoding of
personal memories and the influence of societal norms and taboos on the
construction of autobiographical stories. Moreover, the concept of traumatic
experiences and their psychological impact is deeply embedded in cultural
narratives, shaping understandings of conditions like multiple personality
disorder.
Narrative psychology further explores how
autobiographical narratives are influenced by cultural patterns and societal
expectations. Stories of trauma and crisis often follow familiar cultural
scripts, reflecting broader social narratives surrounding suffering and
resilience. The narrative construction of the self, therefore, occurs within a
cultural framework that shapes both memory and identity.
No comments:
Post a Comment