Tuesday, 9 January 2024

Paul Smith's "Discerning the Subject" (Book Note)

 


"Discerning the Subject," explores the theoretical frameworks of Marxism, deconstruction, psychoanalysis, and feminism concerning the concept of the subject. The author, David L. Smith, endeavors to revitalize the notion of human agency within the context of poststructuralist discussions on the "de-centering" of the subject. Critiquing both traditional humanism and poststructuralist perspectives, Smith argues for the importance of theorizing "resistance." While criticizing the former for its flawed epistemology, he challenges the latter on political grounds, asserting that an emphasis on the de-centered subject leads to an inert political culture.

 

Smith's political argument aims to lay the groundwork for a theoretically informed and politically active culture, but it encounters intellectual contradictions. The desire to simplify targets, particularly deconstructive thought, and the adoption of theoretically contradictory positions weaken the overall argument. The book begins with a critical assertion that current conceptions of the subject produce a purely theoretical subject divorced from political and ethical realities. Smith proposes a different concept of the subject, using the etymological pun of "to cern" and "to cerne." The former, meaning "to accept an inheritance or patrimony," aligns with the humanist notion of the subject, while the latter, meaning "to encircle" or "to enclose," symbolizes the subject's passive reception of discursive determinations. The central project is to discern the subject, arguing that the human agent surpasses the constructed subject in poststructuralist theory and opposing discourses.

Smith critiques both humanism and poststructuralism but views the former as crippled by its epistemology and seeks to incorporate the theoretical advances of the latter into a more flexible theoretical discourse. He introduces the concept of the "agent," a form of subjectivity allowing for resistance to ideological pressure due to contradictions and disturbances in subject positions. Smith, however, faces challenges in explaining the meaning and manifestation of resistance.

 

While expressing concern about totalizing critical positions, Smith hesitates to elaborate on the truism that totalizing impulses are connected with totalitarianism. Against deterministic Marxist criticism, Smith favors an Althusserian Marxism that acknowledges the permanence of ideology and diverse possibilities for subjective interpellation. He sees potential for change emerging from the plurality and contradictions of ideological discourses, exploring how the force of interpellation can fail to produce a compliant subject and examining the contestatory use of that failure. Smith's project aims to theorize agential subjectivity from the simultaneous non-unity and non-consistency of subject positions, emphasizing negativity as the productive moment in rewriting Althusser.

In his critique of Althusser, Smith praises Althusser for integrating psychoanalytic theory into Marxism but faults him for what he sees as an essentialism of the unconscious. Smith argues that Althusser's concept of ideology represents an imaginary relationship, akin to false consciousness, perpetuating a dualism that anticipates the liberal subject's Utopian promise of a total individual. He claims that the literary criticism following Althusser, especially that of Macherey and Screen writers, falls into a deterministic trap, neglecting the distinction between subject-positions in a text and the actual human agent engaging with it.

 

Moving to deconstruction, Smith analyzes Derrida's thought, criticizing it without a substantial engagement with Derrida's texts or acknowledgment of the performative aspects of writing. Smith summarizes Derrida's argument on the persistence of the signifier and the absence of an originary text in the unconscious. However, he misinterprets Derrida's stance as passive, overlooking the complexity of Derrida's thinking and reducing it to automatic writing. By neglecting the performative and contextual aspects of Derrida's work, Smith's critique appears one-sided and fails to capture the depth of Derrida's contributions.

According to Smith, Derrida and Derridean literary theory, which he playfully labels "Derridadaist" literary criticism, have contributed to the "textualization of all objects of knowledge." Smith coins the term "holotextualism" to describe this interpretive practice, which he views as dangerously solipsistic and nihilistic. He criticizes narrative theory for neglecting the relationship between narrative and subjectivity, as well as its impact on social formations. However, this critique appears untenable given the nuanced work of contemporary literary critics like Leo Bersani, Samuel Weber, and Franco Moretti, who explore these topics with sophistication.

 

Smith's assessment of narrative theory and narrative itself seems inadequate and reliant on clichés, particularly when dismissing classic realism as a "thoroughly constrained" form of artistic production. This theoretical glibness and rhetorical register raise concerns about the depth of Smith's engagement with these subjects. His wariness of narrative, possibly due to its libidinal allure, contradicts Lacan's understanding of the imaginary's role in psychic constitution alongside the symbolic. A notable strength in the book is Smith's critique of Althusser for reducing Lacan's ternary scheme to a dyad, neglecting the complexity of the symbolic and imaginary in shaping the subject. Smith advocates for a psychoanalytic approach that explores the ongoing interplay of the imaginary and symbolic in an individual's history as a source of resistance to ideological binds, avoiding reliance on abstract concepts like false consciousness and will.

 

 

 

 

 

Zamora and Faris, "Magical Realism:Theory, History, Community" (Book Note)


 

Ever since its emergence in Germany in 1925, the term "magical realism" has undergone a dynamic history, experiencing significant shifts in fortune and geographical influence. While it may have lost some of its luster among Latin American authors and scholars who once brought it to prominence in the 1960s, magical realism continues to maintain broad and enduring appeal. This volume, "Magical Realism: Theory, History, Community," skillfully navigates the complex currents that define magical realism's history. The editors, in their Introduction, openly advocate for the transformation of magical realism into an "international commodity," recognizing its continued resonance in the post-colonial world and metropolitan centers.

 

Compiled and executed by two accomplished comparatist scholars with strong Latin Americanist backgrounds, the volume provides a meticulous review of the term's history. The decision to thoroughly revisit the term's evolution adds authority to the editors' efforts. However, there are two notable errors in Latin American literary facts within the volume, specifically regarding Carpentier's novel and the authorship of "El mundo es ancho y ajeno."

 

Out of the 23 essays, ten present new and unpublished material, while the remaining thirteen are reprinted, either in revised or unrevised form, from diverse sources. The opening section features these reprinted essays, including Franz Roh's original 1925 essay and Alejo Carpentier's manifesto from the 1940s. The editors' intention to widen the scope of magical realism is evident in the essays' diverse approaches and the inclusion of primary texts from Europe, America, Africa, and Asia. Essays by John Erickson on French-African novels and Susan Napier's exploration of modern Japanese fiction showcase the volume's effort to extend magical realism beyond its traditional Latin American context. While Latin American boom texts receive less attention, there is a deliberate shift toward examining "post-colonial" literatures, particularly from former British colonies.

The volume organizes its essays into four main sections: Foundations, Theory, History, and Community. While these categories aim to comprehensively explore the subject, the editors acknowledge the challenges of neatly compartmentalizing the diverse facets of magical realism. The "Foundations" section serves as a functional and objective introduction, while the "Community" section reflects the editors' strategic interests. Paradoxically, the "Theory" section often delves into the literary history of magical realism, while the essays in the "History" section incorporate strong theoretical perspectives into their discussions of historical contexts.

 

"Magical Realism: Theory, History, Community" does not claim to offer definitive solutions to the theoretical and historical challenges posed by the term. Some essays suggest that magical realism might simply refer to works following the style of Gabriel Garcia Márquez's "One Hundred Years of Solitude." However, certain essays are criticized for reducing magical realism to a purely textual phenomenon. The most compelling essays, in contrast, are those that strive to specify and diversify the concept. They identify various kinds and strands of magical realism, recognizing the local and concrete uses and functions of magical realist elements. Noteworthy contributions in this regard come from essays by D'haen, Delbaere-Garant, and Parkinson Zamora.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Shohat & Sam, "Unthinking Eurocentrism:Multiculturalism and the Media" (Book Note)


 

 

"Unthinking Eurocentrism: Multiculturalism and the Media" takes on the challenging task of critically examining power structures and discourses that stem from Eurocentrism in contemporary media representations. Ella Shohat and Robert Stam aim to completely rethink media subjectivities by deconstructing commonly understood terms and theories, destabilizing national imaginaries, and challenging the foundations of Eurocentrism. They adopt an adversarial approach, acting as scholars, educators, and activists to question Eurocentrism as an implicit subject positioning. They emphasize the importance of combining multiculturalism with the critique of Eurocentrism to avoid merely creating an accretive view of world cultures or simply inverting existing hierarchies. The book aims not to diminish Europe but to deconstruct Eurocentrism, making Europe one of many sources of culture rather than a singular one. Through a vast array of mass media examples in film, video, and music, as well as historical references, Shohat and Stam provide a comprehensive analysis. The journey they propose spans temporal, spatial, disciplinary, intertextual, and conceptual dimensions, creating a tapestry that mirrors the interdependence of cultural communities at the heart of multiculturalism.

"Unthinking Eurocentrism: Multiculturalism and the Media" is a valuable resource for advanced undergraduate or graduate classes, given its depth and complexity. The book assumes a certain level of reader knowledge and familiarity with a wide range of concepts and textual examples. Some concepts are briefly mentioned without detailed explanations, and many films are named but not extensively discussed. While it may complement the reading list for first-year media graduate students, incorporating it into an introduction to graduate studies seminar or other advanced classes would be more effective.

 

For undergraduates, the book may pose challenges as the vast array of films mentioned may not be accessible for viewing, making it a potentially frustrating exercise. However, the discussions of genre and in-depth textual analyses could provide balance to other undergraduate readings. For teachers of undergraduates, "Unthinking Eurocentrism" serves as a valuable resource, offering suggestions for curricular design, discussions of films suitable for class, and general insights for introducing multiculturalism into the classroom.

 

The authors define "Eurocentrism" as a construct that sanitizes Western history while patronizing the non-West, considering itself in terms of noble achievements while viewing the non-West in terms of deficiencies. "Multiculturalism," in their view, is a term pointing to a debate rather than having inherent meaning. They propose pushing multiculturalism toward a radical critique of power relations and emphasize the need for ethnic relationality and community answerability.

 

The book sets out to restructure and reconceptualize power relations between cultural communities, providing a framework for debate. Spanning Africa, Asia, the Americas, and Europe, it highlights the interdependence among cultural communities. The media examples encompass dominant, counter, and resistant media, and theoretical insights are drawn from both Western and non-Western scholars. The book also offers insights on reorganizing media courses and film/video canons within each chapter.

 

 

The core idea driving the desire to "unthink Eurocentrism" and advocate for a radical multiculturalism is the belief that most places in the world are inherently hybrid and syncretic. The narrowly defined and sometimes arbitrary modes of representing these places are not natural but result from institutional discourses and power relations. Media representations play a crucial role in identity construction, contributing to the isolation or affiliation of groups of people. Shohat and Stam focus on discursive practices inherited from the colonial period, asserting that despite contemporary concerns with multiculturalism, it is not a new phenomenon.

 

In Chapter One, "From Eurocentrism to Polycentrism," the authors deconstruct terms and theories with intricate histories such as "West/East," "race/racism," "colonialism," and "Third World." They illustrate the constructed nature of each term, the representational tropes they generate, and how these concepts have become blurred over time. Shohat and Stam emphasize the ambiguities of terms like "postcoloniality" and "hybridity" to set the parameters of their exploration. The material draws from film and media studies, cultural studies, psychoanalytic theory, post-structuralism, history, and colonial literature, demonstrating a cross-disciplinary approach aimed at political and politicizing rethinking of media.

 

Chapter Two, "Formations of Colonialist Discourse," delves into the history of colonialist discourse, revealing the shift in representation and relations between Africa and Europe post-1492. The authors show how colonialist discourse, rooted in the past, has shaped contemporary debates and representations. Cinematic representations, inheriting colonialist discourse, have contributed to the creation and perpetuation of an ideological positioning of the "Other." Shohat and Stam explore representations of Columbus's arrival in the Americas and subsequent colonization, emphasizing how cinematic recreations of the past reshape the imagination of the present and legitimize or interrogate hegemonic memories.

 

Chapter Three, "The Imperialist Imaginary," argues that cinema, as the world's storyteller, has played a crucial role in relaying projected narratives of nations and empires. The beginnings of cinema coinciding with the imperial project made it an ideal medium to project narratives of national self-consciousness linked to cinematic fictions. The chapter highlights the interconnectedness of cinema with imperialistic narratives and discusses how national self-consciousness became broadly linked to cinematic fictions. The authors analyze various films, including those commemorating Columbus, to illustrate the cinema's role in shaping imperialist imaginaries.

 

 

In their examination of discrete genres and representations of colonialism, Shohat and Stam focus on the Western and adventure films. They argue that cinema, serving as both science and spectacle, was particularly adept at creating and sustaining national imaginaries. The authors trace "the imperialist imaginary" from early to contemporary cinema, emphasizing its role in idealizing the colonial enterprise. The analysis includes examples from the Lumière brothers' early portrayals of North Africans to modern films like INDIANA JONES. The chapter illustrates how dominant cinema has spoken for the "winners" of history and shaped imperialist imaginaries over time.

 

Chapter Four, "Tropes of Empire," explores various representational tropes that underlie and reinforce the national imaginary. Shohat and Stam analyze gendered tropes connecting the colonized to eroticized geographies, dark continents, veiled territories, and symbolic fantasies of rape and rescue. They examine representations of women and non-Western bodies, using a blend of Freudian psychoanalysis and post-structuralism. The authors explore connections between cinema, history, anthropology, archeology, and cartography, emphasizing Hollywood's role in asserting historical and empirical knowledge through narratives pretending to these disciplines. The chapter contrasts mainstream cinema with examples from documentary and counter-practice, providing thought-provoking observations.

 

Chapters Five and Six, "Stereotype, Realism, and the Struggle Over Representation" and "Ethnicities-in-Relation," address issues of verisimilitude, truth in representation, the struggle over representation, and latent multiculturalism. The authors contend that filmic fictions inevitably bring real-life assumptions about space, time, and social/cultural relationships. They advocate for a shift from focusing on images to studying discourse, emphasizing the importance of understanding the institutions disseminating mass media texts and the audiences receiving them. Shohat and Stam argue that marginalized groups historically lacked control over their representation, making it crucial to read texts "from the margins" to reveal submerged cultural voices near the surface.

In "Unthinking Eurocentrism," Shohat and Stam highlight two key ideas. Firstly, they emphasize that stereotypes of marginalized peoples exist not only in Western but also non-Western mass media, illustrating the pervasive nature of Eurocentric thought. Casting choices, linguistic decisions, and audience expectations contribute to these representations. The authors assert that self-representation goes beyond marginalized individuals gaining control of production tools; it involves understanding stereotypes as part of a continuum influenced by various forces. The privileging of discursive analysis encourages recognizing that stereotyped representations are intertwined with other sociocultural factors.

 

Secondly, Shohat and Stam advocate for a syncretic understanding of multicultural societies, urging scholars to move beyond race-based binaries and consider ethnicities within ethnic groups. They use "The Jazz Singer" as an example, highlighting the need for a relational approach that considers both racial and ethnic dimensions. The authors argue for a multicultural approach that recognizes the interdependence of cultural communities in diverse populations. This syncretism is linguistic and cultural, fostering a conflictual yet creative intermingling of cultures. Chapters Five and Six link racial and ethnic representations to the multicultural society, challenging readers to rethink not only media representation but also their own perspectives shaped by these representations.

 

Chapters Seven and Eight shift the focus to specific films made by Third World filmmakers, exploring "The Third Worldist Film" and "Esthetics of Resistance." These chapters examine historical and contemporary radical political cinemas, showcasing films that counter Eurocentrism and propose alternative truths. The films presented attack Eurocentrism through formal innovation and a rejection or reconfiguration of hegemonic Hollywood conventions. Shohat and Stam underscore the radical potential of multicultural film and video practices, emphasizing that these works offer counter-narratives and counter-truths informed by an anti-colonialist perspective.

 

The authors conclude the book by discussing the relevance and radical implications of "unthinking Eurocentrism" for the classroom. They emphasize the indispensable need for re-envisioning global politics and advocate for a pedagogical approach that includes the deconstruction of spectatorship. In doing so, they provide practical suggestions for rethinking audiovisual pedagogy. "Unthinking Eurocentrism" is recognized as an important and groundbreaking work, offering a truly multicultural and interdisciplinary approach to media studies.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Monday, 8 January 2024

Timothy Brennan's "Salman Rushdie and the Third World: Myths of the Nation" (Book Note)


 

Timothy Brennan’s book primarily revolves around a detailed exploration of Rushdie's four novels: Grimus, Midnight's Children, Shame, and The Satanic Verses. This examination is guided by the initial two chapters, which establish crucial contexts for understanding Rushdie's work. These contexts include the role of fiction in contemporary nationalism, and conversely, how nationalism influences fiction. Additionally, the relationship between Third-World literary cosmopolitanism and anti-colonial liberalism is explored. This approach allows the book to simultaneously position Rushdie as both a unique individual and a representative figure. It enables the book to establish and question the role of internationally renowned Third-World writers in shaping post-colonial discourse.

 

While some categorization strategies may lean towards being overly prescriptive, such as the provision of a two-columned checklist of differences between "postmodernists" and "Third-World cosmopolitans," overall, this analysis presents an original and engaging exploration of a complex subject.

 

Throughout his argument, Brennan indirectly suggests why the Rushdie affair captured the attention of both liberal and less liberal Western minds. The "Third-World cosmopolitan" writers, with whom Brennan associates Rushdie, are characterized by their constant evasion of fixed national and ideological identities, which has become a defining characteristic of humane cosmopolitan writers from the Third World. One obvious result of this evasion is the translation of "authorial ambiguity" into a dualistic moral framework where every group is assigned both a positive and negative expression. Brennan identifies this radical relativity as a governing principle of duality in much of Rushdie's work.

 

This mode of translation inevitably leads to an ambiguous relationship with authority and tradition, and only a slightly more stable connection with an immigrant culture that lacks the former and strives to establish the latter. Twentieth-century English liberalism has often appeared, at one extreme, as nothing more than the refined high-mindedness portrayed by Forster (material that Rushdie criticizes as ripe for cinematic "Raj revisionism"), or at the other extreme, a form of Orwellian slumming. Brennan's portrayal of Rushdie, despite his outrage in the face of Thatcher's England or the Ayatollah's Iran, suggests that he cannot entirely avoid the pitfalls faced by well-intentioned political efforts due to his gender and class.

 

 

If there is a concern about "the way Rushdie often depicts women" (126), Brennan seems to find this issue ultimately less troublesome than the disconnect between Rushdie's refined upbringing, shaped by public school and Cambridge, and the experiences of "the people," particularly those striving to find their voice within Britain's diverse black cultures. The former cultivates detachment, while the latter demands engagement. This issue is most directly addressed in the discussion of The Satanic Verses. Despite the distortions in media coverage, Brennan argues that the novel primarily centers on a very secular England (147). The offense taken by "ordinary lower-class Muslims in India and Pakistan—along with those in the English cities of Bradford, Birmingham, and London" indicates, for Brennan, "the class resentments simmering beneath the surface of an affair that has often been viewed solely through religious lenses" (145).

 

Brennan's own allegiances, as outlined in his earlier analysis of decolonization, which positions Third-World cosmopolitanism in contrast to the work of pragmatic theorists like Antonio Gramsci, José Carlos Mariátegui, Amílcar Cabrai, and Frantz Fanon, become more apparent towards the end of the final chapter. Here, Brennan adopts a Fielding-to-Rushdie dynamic, critiquing the detached and insensitive nature of cosmopolitan 'universality.' While Rushdie contends that "bigotry is not only a function of power," Brennan suggests that in the specific immigration and acculturation complexities of contemporary Britain, the central issue may not be solely one of 'human evil'. The means of perpetuating this evil are evidently highly unequal, and the violence stemming from defending one's identity or livelihood as opposed to one's privileges is not equivalent (165).

 

If this is indeed a truth, it's a perspective Salman Rushdie has likely been in a uniquely uncomfortable position to acknowledge, at least since February 14, 1989, compared to Timothy Brennan. Behind the occasional surface-level identification with the oppressed lies a serious and nuanced examination not only of Rushdie himself, but also of the paradoxes experienced by Third-World intellectuals. These intellectuals may not be the most equipped agents to address the problem of our collective struggle to recognize the colonial perspective as one that truly matters (166).

 

Luso-tropicalism

 

The concept of luso-tropicalism was formulated by Brazilian sociologist Gilberto Freyre in a trilogy of books published from 1933, known as The Masters and the Slaves, The Mansions and the Shanties, and Order and Progress. Although the term 'luso-tropicalism' was coined later in the 1950s, it serves to encapsulate Freyre's interconnected ideas about Brazil and Portuguese colonialism.

 

In The Masters and the Slaves, Freyre outlines the fundamental aspects of the concept. He suggests that extensive mixing, or 'miscegenation,' occurred in Brazil among people of European, African, and native Amerindian descent, resulting in a subtle and complex blend. This mixing was influenced by the Portuguese colonists' decision to establish a sugar monoculture using a large-scale farming model. The colonists, a small and mostly male group, justified enslavement and intermingling with the native Amerindian population due to a perceived shortage of labor. Once the nomadic culture of the native population was disrupted by the Portuguese emphasis on settled ranches and fixed labor, African slaves took their place.

Gilberto Freyre, a Brazilian sociologist, developed the concept of luso-tropicalism in his trilogy of books published from 1933. This term was coined in the 1950s to encapsulate Freyre's ideas about Brazil and Portuguese colonialism. He argued that the three-way mixing of different racial groups, based on pseudoscientific notions of "biological stock," led to a profound blending of culture in Brazil. This blending was so extensive that little of the original group culture remained, especially compared to the more defined cultures in the United States.

 

Freyre believed that the history of the Iberian peninsula predisposed Portuguese settlers to both biological and cultural mixing, with a more benevolent governing ethos than in British or French colonies. The hybridization of Portuguese culture, influenced by the dynamic between Portuguese and Moorish culture on the Iberian peninsula, was already present when settlers arrived in Brazil. The warm climate of the Iberian peninsula also prepared Portuguese colonists for the hot weather in Brazil.

 

Despite Freyre's exposure to cultural anthropologist Franz Boas, luso-tropicalism, like the concept of hybridity, considers both biology and culture. Freyre differentiated African groups in Brazil, sometimes emphasizing cultural superiority based on Islamic influences, but at other times resorting to biological differences. His depiction of Brazilian "family life" was racially inflected, at times bordering on racism.

 

Responses to Freyre's concept varied. During Getúlio Vargas's authoritarian rule, luso-tropicalism inspired the idea of Brazilian "racial democracy" and national identity. However, scholar Florestan Fernandes highlighted racial divisions and discrimination faced by Afro-Brazilians in Sao Paulo. The concept was also used by governing elites in Brazil and Portugal to address calls for independence from Portugal's African colonies in the 1960s.

 

 

 

 

 

Intercultural Translation

 'Intercultural translation,' as conceptualized by Boaventura de Sousa Santos, involves bringing together diverse knowledge systems without suppressing or sidelining any of them. The idea is to facilitate a dialogue between different knowledge frameworks rooted in distinct cosmologies. Intercultural translation serves as a tool to initiate conversations that reveal overlooked knowledge and make various forms of oppression understandable.

 

In practical terms, Santos sees intercultural translation as a means of empowering marginalized groups, especially in the Global South. It goes beyond being a theoretical concept and should be applied in the political realm. Therefore, interpolitical and intercultural translation are interconnected and function together. This approach establishes a system of languages through which communal resistance efforts collaborate. Politically and culturally, intercultural translation develops a vocabulary that challenges and moves away from the Western universal paradigm.

 

In contrast to the Western paradigm, intercultural translation focuses on creating a knowledge system from the perspective of the Global South. It addresses the historical erasure and marginalization of certain groups due to Western ideas of inferiority. Intercultural translation goes beyond individual actions; it's a collective effort that revitalizes marginalized cultures, introducing new ways of thinking, knowledge constellations, and alternative ways of existence.

 

The goal of intercultural translation is to establish a foundation for achieving 'global social and cognitive justice.' Essentially, it seeks to fuel the creation of different possible worlds. Intercultural translation emphasizes both the existence of differences and similarities, facilitating the development of social connections among movements opposing colonialism, capitalism, imperialism, and patriarchy. This opens up the potential for a grassroots political collaboration.

Sunday, 7 January 2024

Smith's "Socrates on Self-Improvement: Knowledge, Virtue and Happiness" (Book Note)

 In this insightful book, Nicholas Smith offers a fresh perspective on Plato's Socratic dialogues, particularly regarding the pursuit of happiness through virtue and knowledge. While Socrates emphasizes the connection between happiness (eudaimonia), virtue, and knowledge, his quest to define virtue is marked by repeated failures. This leaves readers in a dilemma: they are told that to attain happiness, they must cultivate virtue, yet receive little concrete guidance on how to do so. Some scholars even contend that Socrates suggests death as a preferable alternative to the pursuit of virtue. However, Smith presents a more optimistic interpretation, asserting that genuine progress toward virtue and happiness is within reach for all.

 

Smith's key argument revolves around redefining Socratic knowledge. He contends that considering Socratic knowledge as craft-like ("knowledge-how") rather than propositional ("knowledge-that") offers a more accurate understanding. Unlike propositional knowledge, which is binary, craft knowledge is gradable, allowing for varying degrees of proficiency. Viewing Socratic knowledge in this light allows for the possibility of incremental progress towards virtue and, subsequently, happiness.

 

This craft knowledge interpretation yields several interpretive benefits. It naturally aligns with Socrates' use of crafts as an analogy for virtue and resolves the apparent paradox of Socrates being both an exemplar of virtue and yet still ignorant. Additionally, it provides a coherent explanation for Socrates' exhortation to become as wise as possible. Nevertheless, it raises questions about the role of definitional knowledge, which seems more aligned with the propositional model. The Socratic method often involves questioning purported experts about the definition of a virtue. Smith argues that definitional knowledge isn't always central to Socratic discussions of craft knowledge. For instance, in the case of swimming, being able to articulate a definition doesn't seem critical to possessing the skill. However, Smith concedes that Socrates does suggest that a true master of virtue should be able to explain and teach it.

 

This interpretation prompts further considerations about the distinction between true belief and knowledge, as well as Socrates' assertion that knowledge is always true. These issues invite a deeper exploration of how Socratic craft knowledge interfaces with these foundational concepts.

 

Smith's book goes on to unpack the notion of moral improvability, offering a nuanced understanding of Socrates' claim to have taken up the true craft of politics. This involves not just aspiring to wisdom, but actively acquiring degrees of it. Additionally, Smith delves into the interplay between epistemology and moral psychology, illuminating how non-rational states influence belief formation. He explores how these states, rooted in fear, shame, anger, and others, shape ethical development, underscoring that all wrongdoing stems from ignorance. Further, Smith delves into Socratic ignorance and elenchos, elucidating how epistemic modesty and decision-making from the standpoint of ignorance play pivotal roles in ethical improvement.

Chapters 5 and 6 delve into the connection between craft knowledge and happiness. In Chapter 5, Smith explores the sufficiency of virtue for happiness. He argues that while virtue leads to doing well, it may not necessarily equate to happiness. Smith illustrates this point by referencing the case of "Sully" Sullenberger, the commercial pilot who executed a heroic emergency landing, saving all passengers. While Sully's actions were undoubtedly commendable, describing his condition as "happy" would be a stretch. This highlights the distinction between doing well and experiencing true happiness, prompting a reevaluation of our understanding of Socratic accounts.

 

Smith also addresses the notion of Socratic harm and human vulnerability. He contends that external factors can make individuals susceptible to moral corruption, such as through improper teaching or familial influences. This interpretation humanizes Socrates and underscores his recognition of the potential impact of external circumstances on ethical development.

 

In Chapter 6, Smith argues that virtue is a necessary component of happiness, but it need not be an all-or-nothing concept. This nuanced perspective aligns with the Socratic mission, emphasizing the possibility of genuine progress toward virtue and happiness.

 

The book concludes with a thoughtful reflection on the philosophical merits of Smith's interpretation. While acknowledging the importance of interpretative accuracy, Smith suggests that it should not overshadow the broader pursuit of philosophical truth. This afterword encourages scholars to engage in meaningful discussions about the relevance and applicability of Socratic philosophy to contemporary philosophical inquiries.

Michel Foucault, "Discipline and Punish" || Chapter Summary ||

  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (Chapter Summaries) Part I: Torture Chapter 1: The Body of the Condemned Foucault opens the...